# Turn 2 · model calls

The full recorded input, reasoning, tool calls and lifecycle of every model call placed on [turn 2](/games/game-11/turns/2.md), grouped by seat. Each call has its own anchor (`#d-<id>`). The same records are rows of [decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl).

[Previous turn's calls](/games/game-11/turns/1-calls.md) · [Next turn's calls](/games/game-11/turns/3-calls.md)

## Model calls linked to this turn

Calls with an accepted-event join or a recorded refusal in this turn.

### alice-legacy-p0009 {#d-alice-legacy-p0009}

Seat: alice. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 9. Active turn: True.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/alice-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/alice-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

- [Event #19](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e19) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join
- [Event #20](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e20) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

```json
{"kind": "supersede", "hit": true}
```

**Recorded input**

```text
POOL MESSAGE from bob (event #17): Your 4 actions — ride request (default, veto freely): dispatcherMove ME along the land bridge: Buenos Aires→Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo. Ends me adjacent to BOTH Baghdad(3⚠, only live bomb) and Riyadh(1), one step off Khartoum — meaning your later yellow deliverable converges with my black sweep for free. Why this beats the revived Essen run: blues peaked at 2-per-city tonight and blue discs are shielded (pHit≈0 unless epidemic ~18%); black is the color actually accreting supply pressure (Baghdad 3 + Mumbai 2 + four 1s) AND it's YOUR cure color — I'm clearing ground under your black set while your draws find its 3 missing cards. Since SA is now quiet you're freed from the Bogota leg entirely; after the ride stay east-mounted, consider Miami→LA→Sydney drift toward red/Asia next turns. Hand update: drew Tokyo(red) — held for you (red fuel/handoff), Madrid(blue) kept per blueprint.

ACTIVE TURN — it is your move.

STANDING TEAM PLAN (alice, pinned 1 of your turn(s) ago):
  REGIONS: bob(medic) owns EUROPE-blues→blacks: t+1 treat Madrid (chain-dropped there by alice), then Essen→StP → blue eradication target t+2-3, then sweep black via Istanbul/Cairo→Baghdad 3⚠. alice(dispatcher) owns AMERICAS+yellows: Miami→Bogota corridor, defuse Buenos Aires 3⚠ (~t+2-3, costs her 3 treats), feed own black/red sets. HANDS: alice keeps Khartoum/Riyadh/Karachi/Shanghai; bob keeps SF/Kinshasa/Johannesburg (cure sets), Bangkok red is fuel/handoff-to-alice. NO dedicated card-meet trips (Khartoum/Bangkok handoffs shelved unless coincidental, per bob). Bombs to watch in infect-discard: Baghdad, Buenos Aires, Essen/StP until cleared.
If the board has invalidated this plan or it is complete, replace it via
pin_plan — until then, your partner is assuming you are following it.
CONFLICT RULE: when your own read of the board — a signal, the DECISION
FRONTIER, a preview result — argues against this plan, do NOT silently
obey and do NOT silently deviate. CALL send_message naming the conflict
(the city and what you would do instead), then resolve it: your partner's
reply or a fresh pin_plan. A stale pin never outranks the live board.

ACTION ECONOMY: you have 4 action(s) left this turn against 1 city(ies) at 3 cubes and 3 at 2. Unused actions are lost forever — passing or ending your turn now spends your scarcest resource (4/turn) on nothing. Unless you are a Quarantine Specialist holding a shield over a hot cluster, spend it: treat, or move toward the nearest hot city. A pointless move away and back is not action economy.

TRIAGE: the DECISION FRONTIER below prices this turn's rival plans
against each other. Pick a line, extend it, or beat it with your own
plan via preview_plan; split targets with teammates either way.

=== STATE ===
phase=playerActions turnOwner=alice  (actions left: 4)
you=alice role=dispatcher at=Miami
cures: blue:none yellow:none black:none red:none  outbreaks=0/8  infectionRate=2
stations: Atlanta
players: alice@Miami(dispatcher) hand=6 [Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Buenos Aires(yellow), Santiago(yellow)]  bob@Buenos Aires(medic) hand=6 [Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue)]
supply: blue:18 yellow:24 black:15 red:23   decks: player=45 infection=35   player-discard: —
threats (cube counts, cluster membership, supply pressure, route cost from you, infect-discard — one row per city):
  Baghdad: 3 black⚠ [in infect-discard] — 6 move(s): Washington→New York→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad — nearer teammate: bob, 5 move(s) vs your 6
  Essen: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 4 move(s): Washington→New York→London→Essen
  Mumbai: 2 black [in infect-discard] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 6 move(s): Mexico City→Los Angeles→Sydney→Jakarta→Chennai→Mumbai
  St. Petersburg: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 5 move(s): Washington→New York→London→Essen→St. Petersburg
  Riyadh: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Ho Chi Minh City: 1 red [in infect-discard]
  Kolkata: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Moscow: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  New York: 1 blue [in infect-discard]
  Karachi: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Toronto: 1 blue [in infect-discard]

=== SIGNALS ===
deck clock: 45 cards → 22 player-turn(s) of draws left; 4 cure(s) still needed → one cure every ~5 turn(s), team-wide
eradication: none in reach
DISPATCHER REACH (your turn moves ANY pawn — jump one onto a teammate's city for 1 action at any distance, or drive it 1 city/action; both card-free):
  Baghdad(black): drive bob 5 step(s) to Baghdad → then that pawn treats
cure plan — TEAM-WIDE collector assignment (cures WIN the game; treating only buys time):
  blue: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your blue cards when you share
  yellow: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your yellow cards when you share
  black: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY black card; nearest station Atlanta (1 move(s))
  red: YOU collect (1/5) — keep EVERY red card; nearest station Atlanta (1 move(s))
share rendezvous — TEAM-WIDE transfer routes (cards in the wrong hand + where to meet):
  hand Buenos Aires(yellow) to bob: meet IN Buenos Aires (the card's own city) — you 2 move(s), bob 0 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +3 move(s) to cure
  hand Santiago(yellow) to bob: meet IN Santiago (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure
  hand Khartoum(yellow) to bob: meet IN Khartoum (the card's own city) — you 4 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +5 move(s) to cure
station opportunities (stations enable cures and shuttle travel):
  you hold Buenos Aires, 2 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 3 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~6 action(s) on remaining cure runs: blue 3→0, yellow 3→0) — costs Buenos Aires(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Buenos Aires 3→0, Sao Paulo 3→1, Lagos 4→2, Kinshasa 5→3; board-wide: 20 cities closer, 27 trip-actions shaved
  you hold Santiago, 3 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 4 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~0 action(s) on current cure runs) — costs Santiago(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Santiago 4→0, Lima 3→1; board-wide: 2 cities closer, 6 trip-actions shaved

⚠ DECISION FRONTIER — 2 rival turn-plan(s); NONE dominates another.
NOT a ranking — a curve between the two ways to lose. DOWN trades cure-pipeline
actions for fewer expected outbreaks; UP reverses it. No line is best: pick the
end facing whichever clock is closer to killing you.
  clocks — outbreaks 0/8; deck ~22 turn(s), 4 cure(s) still needed
Priced nominees, not orders — pick one, extend it, or beat it via preview_plan.
  - advance the yellow cure: hand off a card at Buenos Aires (bob collects, 3 still needed) — drive Bogota, drive Buenos Aires, shareGive
     tempo: 6 action(s) closer to the yellow cure (28 → 22 action(s) to land it) — bob collects | risk after: ~0.0 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases + 1 armed discard bomb(s) (Baghdad): P(epidemic in window) ≈ 44%, and the reshuffle re-arms them ALL — ~1 chained outbreak(s) committed over the ~7 infect phase(s) after it, cancelable ONLY by treating them before it fires
  - defuse the armed discard bomb at Baghdad (black — fires on the next epidemic reshuffle) — drive Washington, drive New York, drive Madrid, drive Algiers
     tempo: 1 action(s) further from the yellow cure (28 → 29 action(s) to land it) — bob collects | risk after: ~0.0 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases + 1 armed discard bomb(s) (Baghdad): P(epidemic in window) ≈ 44%, and the reshuffle re-arms them ALL — ~1 chained outbreak(s) committed over the ~7 infect phase(s) after it, cancelable ONLY by treating them before it fires; en route to clear black at Baghdad — worth ~8 cube(s)+chain when finished, but the clear lands AFTER this window: the next 2 infect phases face the board as-is
  exchange "advance the yellow cure: hand off a card at Bue…" → "defuse the armed discard bomb at Baghdad": gives up 7 action(s) of cure progress to move risk ~0.0 expected outbreaks → ~0.0
  dominated: "break the Essen–St. Petersburg blue cluster at Essen" — tempo -3 vs -1, risk 0.45 vs 0.27 — beaten by "defuse the armed discard bomb at Baghdad"
  SPLIT DECISION — this antichain holds a cure line AND a containment line
  and neither dominates: that is a TEAM call, not a solo one. Before you
  commit, CALL send_message with your pick and a one-line reason so your
  partner can veto or extend it — a silent choice here is how chains get
  missed.

Your legal actions — this is the COMPLETE legal set; anything not named
here will be rejected. A `[n] {...}` line is literal: pass it verbatim to
submit_action.action. A grouped family gives a template plus the values
allowed in it: fill the template with one combination shown on a single
line and pass that.
  [0] {"tag":"pass"}
  [1] {"tag":"endActions"}
  driveFerry — 4 options; build {"tag":"driveFerry","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Atlanta", "Washington", "Mexico City", "Bogota"
  directFlight — 6 options; build {"tag":"directFlight","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Shanghai", "Khartoum", "Riyadh", "Karachi", "Buenos Aires", "Santiago"
  [12] {"tag":"dispatcherJump","pawn":"alice","toPawn":"bob"}
  [13] {"tag":"dispatcherJump","pawn":"bob","toPawn":"alice"}
  [14] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [15] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  [16] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Kinshasa"}
  [17] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Bangkok"}
  [18] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"San Francisco"}
  [19] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Johannesburg"}
  [20] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Tokyo"}
  [21] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Madrid"}
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

Step 1 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Let me work through this turn carefully.

Current state:
- alice (me, dispatcher) at Miami, 4 actions, hand: Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Buenos Aires(yellow), Santiago(yellow) — 6 cards.
- bob (medic) at Buenos Aires, hand: Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue) — 6 cards.

Wait — bob is at Buenos Aires? His message says "drew Tokyo(red)" and the state shows bob@Buenos Aires with hand [Kinshasa, Bangkok, San Francisco, Johannesburg, Tokyo, Madrid]. He's at Buenos Aires with Madrid in hand — meaning he must have treated Buenos Aires? Supply yellow went 21→24 (+3 back) and blue 16→18 (+2). So during his turn he treated Buenos Aires (3 yellow cubes removed — wait but medic treats all cubes of a color at once... yellow not cured, so treatDisease removes 1 cube per action for medic when not cured!

Hmm wait. Medic: "Treat Disease removes ALL cubes of a color at once." That's the medic power — it applies even without cure? No! Medic's ability: "The Medic may remove all cubes of a single color on his current city when doing Treat Disease" — actually in base Pandemic, the Medic removes ALL cubes of one color from his city with ONE Treat Disease action, even before cure. Yes — Medic's role description: "may remove all cube(s) of a single color on his current city". The cure bonus is auto-removal just by entering a city.

So bob's turn: he was at BA (I dispatched him there last... no wait, I moved myself to Miami; how did bob get to Buenos Aires? Let me re-trace.

My last turn ended: alice at Miami, bob@Madrid. Then bob's turn happened (advisory at event #10 was before his actions; pool message #17 comes after his full turn). During bob's turn he apparently: drove Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad? No — state shows him at Buenos Aires with blue supply UP by 2 (16→18) and yellow UP by 3 (21→24).

Blue supply up by 2 = two blue cubes treated = Essen had 2 blues? If bob went to Essen and treated, blue would drop 2 cubes → supply +2. But he's at Buenos Aires...

Yellow supply up 3 = BA's 3 yellows removed. Blue up 2 = Essen 2 blues removed? That would require being in two places. Hmm, but the infection phase also runs after each player turn: 2 infections per turn (rate 2). Wait — if infection added cubes, supply would go DOWN. Blue 16→18 means net +2 blue on supply, i.e., 2 blue cubes came OFF the board. Yellow 24-3=21... yellow went UP 3 → 3 yellow cubes came off board (BA cleared).

So bob's turn must have been: (some travel) treat Essen blues (2)... then fly to BA and treat? From Essen to Buenos Aires directly isn't adjacent. Charter flight! Bob doesn't hold Essen or any card that... hmm, charter spends CURRENT city card. Essen→BA via charter needs Essen card which nobody holds.

Alternative: he never went north. Maybe: BA. Actually wait — where did bob end HIS turn? At Buenos Aires per the new state. Last known position from my perspective: bob@Madrid after my chain-ride. Then my final action drove ME Miami. Then bob's turn: from Madrid he could drive Paris/London/NY/Sao Paulo/Algiers. Drive Madrid→Sao Paulo→Buenos Aires takes 2 moves + treat = clears BA's 3 yellows over... medic treats ALL 3 yellows in ONE action (not cured). So: drive Sao Paulo (1), drive BA (1), treat yellow → removes ALL 3 cubes (medic!) = 3 actions. 4th action: ? He stayed BA. And drew Tokyo(red) + Madrid(blue).

But blue supply went 16→18 — that contradicts "no blue treatment". Unless... hmm, +2 blue: wait, maybe I misread earlier values. Previous state (my advisory turn): blue:16 yellow:21 black:16 red:23. Now: blue:18 yellow:24 black:15 red:23.

blue +2, yellow +3, black -1, red same.

Black -1: one black cube placed by infection (Karachi got its first black — Karachi appeared as new threat row with 1 black). So infection phase hit: Karachi (black, 1 cube added from supply -1) — and another city? Rate 2 → two infection cards flipped. New threat rows appearing this round vs last: Karachi (new, 1 black), Toronto (new, 1 blue). Both were previously... Toronto wasn't listed before. So infection flipped: Karachi(1 black) and Toronto(1 blue)? That accounts for black -1 and blue -1... but blue is +2 NET.

So blue: -1 (Toronto infection) +3 = 4 blues treated?? Bob only has 6 cards; did he hold SF/Madrid... Oh wait! BLUE CUBES TREATED: maybe bob went Madrid... no wait. Hmm, let me recount: bob started his turn at... My last submitted action was driveFerry alice Miami. Before that I'd chained bob Atlanta→Washington→NY→Madrid across MY turns. During MY own turn I can't move bob on someone else's... I do move bob (dispatcher power) during MY turn. After my last turn: bob@Madrid, 3 blue there untouched (my messages told him to treat them on HIS turn).

Bob's turn from Madrid: (1) treat blue at Madrid — medic wipes ALL 3 blues in one action! That's blue supply +3. (2) ... then he flew/drived somewhere? Blue net = +3 (Madrid) -1 (Toronto infect) = +2 ✓. 

Then how did he reach BA within remaining 3 actions? Madrid→Sao Paulo? Not adjacent — Madrid neighbors: NY, London, Paris, Algiers, Sao Paulo? Checking map: "Sao Paulo: Madrid, Buenos Aires, Bogota, Lagos" — YES Sao Paulo lists Madrid as neighbor! And "Madrid: London, New York, Paris, Sao Paulo, Algiers". So Madrid↔Sao Paulo ARE connected. So: treat Madrid (wipe 3 blues), drive Sao Paulo, drive Buenos Aires, treat yellow (medic wipes all 3 BA yellows). 4 actions exactly. Drew Tokyo(red) + Madrid(blue). Then infection: Karachi+Toronto fresh flips. And treats: yellow +3, blue +3-1=+2 ✓✓. Black -1 (Karachi). Red unchanged (HCMC already had red? no HCMC still shows 1 red — it stayed because it was already there).

So Madrid bomb DEFUSED (0 blue now), BA bomb DEFUSED (0 yellow). Remaining 3⚠: Baghdad only. Fresh singles: Toronto (1 blue), Karachi (1 black), plus pre-existing Essen/StP 2-blue cluster, Mumbai 2 black, Riyadh/Kolkata/Moscow/Kolkata 1s, HCMC 1 red.

BUT WAIT — threats list shows New York 1 blue disappeared? Previously "New York: 1 blue" existed. Now NOT in threat table. Because NY got treated? Nobody went to NY... Actually threat rows show only cities ≥1 cube presumably; NY had 1 blue last time and it's gone now. Hmm — who treated NY? Nobody. Unless NY row vanished due to table size limits (it lists top-N by severity?). Previous table showed 10 rows including Riyadh 1, Kolkata 1, Moscow 1, HCMC 1, New York 1 — max 10 rows shown. Now we have: Baghdad 3, Essen 2, Mumbai 2, StP 2, Riyadh 1, HCMC 1, Kolkata 1, Moscow 1, NY? missing, Karachi 1, Toronto 1 — that's 10 rows. NY probably dropped off due to row limit. Fine.

Now MY TURN decisions:

Frontier offers:
1. Yellow-cure line: drive Bogota→BA, shareGive Buenos Aires to bob. That kills the "meet IN BA" leg since bob is ALREADY at BA. Tempo says: 6 actions closer to yellow cure (28→22). Because bob holding BA card means yellow set gathering accelerates hugely: bob would have Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA = 3/5 yellows; I keep Khartoum+Santiago = 2/5. Team yellow total 5/5 either way.

Actually wait — think about optimal yellow convergence. All 5 yellow city cards: Kinshasa(bob), Johannesburg(bob), Khartoum(me), Santiago(me), Buenos Aires(me).
Option A: give BA to bob now (he's standing right there): bob has 3 yellow cards {Kinshasa, Jo'burg, BA}; I have {Khartoum, Santiago}. For a cure at Atlanta, need 5 in one hand at station. Bob needs my 2 southern cards OR I need his 3. Kinshasa & Johannesburg are AFRICA cities; I'll be drifting toward Africa/black territory anyway? Meanwhile Santiago (Lima neighbor) is deep south. Khartoum sits between Cairo and Kinshasa.
Natural: bob sweeps black Cairo→Baghdad→back toward Khartoum/Kinshasa region; I could fly Khartoum-direct later... Or: bob swings through Kinshasa/Johannesburg physically to TAKE my Khartoum/Santiago? No — sharing requires the CARD's city meeting unless giver is Researcher.

Better structure: whoever heads south-to-south-America collects Santiago by visiting Santiago with me nearby... complex. Simplest concrete: I give bob BA NOW (1 action, both in BA after my ride over). Then eventually meet in Khartoum to pass Khartoum; Santiago stays mine until I'm near... hmm Santiago route: Jakarta/Sydney side? Sydney-Lima adjacency none. Santiago connects ONLY Lima. Los Angeles-Sydney exists though. Long way.

Alternative orientation: collect yellow into ME instead — I hold 3 (Khartoum, Santiago, BA); take Kinshasa+Johannesburg from bob when I pass through those cities while sweeping southern black? My role region was Americas; but dispatcher can chain-ride BOB for movement while bob does treatments. Honestly the frontier strongly favors giving BA now (tempo 28→22 saves 6 actions!). It's cheap: my ride Miami→Bogota→BA costs 2 actions, shareGive 1 = 3 actions total, leaving 1 spare action. AND it happens with zero epidemic risk since BA is currently CUBE-FREE (just wiped) — driving Bogota corridor passes Mexico City clean.

What about the Baghdad line (frontier option 2): drive Washington→NY→Madrid→Algiers moving ME toward Baghdad — but Baghdad treatment would be done by BOB anyway (his plan: Cairo sweep t+2). Me flying there duplicates. The dispatcher-chained approach is strictly better historically.

Also consider: bob's ride request (message #17): dispatcherMove ME along "Buenos Aires→Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo"? Wait he says ride request for MY pawn? Read again: "Your 4 actions — ride request (default, veto freely): dispatcherMove ME along the land bridge: Buenos Aires→Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo."

"dispatcherMove ME" — he asks me to move HIM along BA→SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo (5 steps, 5 actions!). I only have 4 actions. And that conflicts with the BA-share tempo play. Hmm wait — can't do both fully. His chain: 5 actions needed. Mine: BA-share = 3 actions (drive Bogota, drive BA, shareGive), leaving 1 action → could move bob 1 step (BA→Sao Paulo).

Conflict analysis:
- His goal: get himself to Cairo (adjacent to Baghdad+Riyadh, one step off Khartoum) by end of my turn, so HIS next turn opens with Cairo→Baghdad treat (medic wipes all 3 blacks) + more. 
- Alternative for reaching Cairo: he can walk himself on HIS OWN turn equally well — his actions are interchangeable with my chain-actions except chaining costs MY actions while leaving his 4 free (which his message counts: opens with treat + 3 spares). But if I spend my actions riding him, MY pawn stagnates and the yellow share THIS TURN dies (BA offer expires once he leaves SA!). The share-in-city window closes forever-ish (would need future rendezvous ~expensive).

Tempo math: Yellow share now = 6-action improvement per frontier (28→22). Bob's Cairo ride = positions black containment earlier by one turn; the "yellow cure 6 steps vs black clearance" tradeoff — but note Baghdad is STILL the only live bomb and it's static (no growth without re-flip; re-flip risk starts after an epidemic reshuffle). P(epidemic in window) ≈44% over next 2 phases. Baghdad going 3→outbreak when reshuffled would add ~1 outbreak + spread. We have margin (0/8 used).

Key insight: I CAN'T do both rides fully. Which matters more?

Cure clock: deck 45 cards, ~22 turns of draws, 4 cures needed. Yellow is the closest cure (5/5 cards identified, just logistics). Landing yellow cure early also enables ERADICATION potential and frees medic auto-treatment. Every yellow cube infected later gets auto-wiped by medic walking past. Yellow cure ≈ game-changing acceleration. Black is accreting but slower.

And crucially: my ONE spare action could move bob BA→Sao Paulo anyway, putting him 4 steps from Cairo (SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo = 3 steps? SP-Madrid yes, Madrid-Algiers yes, Algiers-Cairo NO — Algiers neighbors: Madrid, Paris, Cairo ✓ YES Algiers-Cairo connected). So SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo = 3 steps. From BA: 4 steps. If I use all 4 actions: ride Bogota? No wait — if I ride bob instead of sharing...

Decision: YELLOW SHARE NOW (beat the frontier nominee with better sequencing than "drive Bogota, drive Buenos Aires, shareGive" — identical actually: my pawn walks Bogota? Hmm wait, why walk Bogota instead of DIRECT FLIGHT spending the BA card to fly TO Buenos Aires? Direct flight to BA costs the BA CARD ITSELF — defeats the share. Must WALK: Miami→Bogota→BA = 2 drives, then shareGive = 3 actions.)

Then 4th action: dispatcherMove bob →Sao Paulo (starts his bridge ride; he finishes Madrid/Algiers/Cairo on his own turn, arriving Cairo end of his turn +2 actions... he needs SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo = 3 actions of his 4, opening with... hmm his turn: SP→Madrid (1), →Algiers (2), →Cairo (3), treat Baghdad? Not adjacent... Cairo-Baghdad IS adjacent! So arrive Cairo action 3, action 4 treat black at... he'd be IN Cairo treating CAIRO blacks (none yet? Cairo has no cubes currently) — useless. Better: end AT Baghdad: Cairo→Baghdad = 4th step. He has exactly 4 actions: SP(now after my assist)→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad = 4 moves, action 5 unavailable → treats nothing this turn; NEXT turn opens with treat Baghdad (wipe 3) + 3 free. Same as original plan arrival timing (end of HIS next turn... his original proposal: I ride him all 5 steps during MY turn so HE opens with treat immediately).

With my sequencing: bob reaches Baghdad END of his coming turn, treats START of turn after → same relative timing as if I spent 4 actions riding him now EXCEPT I lose the yellow share AND leave my own pawn idle. Wait no: if I ride him 4 steps now (BA→SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo using my dispatcherMove ×4 — chain-riding through multiple cities each action? Each dispatcherMove is one STEP (drive-ferry analog), so 4 actions = 4 steps = arrives Cairo. He then treats Baghdad... not adjacent for treatment! He must DRIVE onto Baghdad (or I'd have had to spend a 5th action). At Cairo with all 4 of HIS actions open: Cairo→Baghdad (1) + treat wipe-all (2) + 2 spares to e.g. treat Riyadh (adjacent to Baghdad: Riyadh neighbors Cairo, Baghdad, Karachi ✓). So his turn yields: Baghdad cleared + Riyadh partially... 

vs my yellow-share version: I give BA card; bob ends his turn at Baghdad via self-drive (SP from my 1-assist: needs 4 of his actions: Madrid/Algiers/Cairo/Baghdad — exactly 4, no treats this turn, but baghdad CLEAR happens next-turn-open with wipes + spares). Timeline difference for Baghdad clear: Plan-Ride: bob treats Baghdad end of his upcoming turn (turn t_bob). Plan-Share: bob treats Baghdad start of t_bob+1. One full player-turn delay. Meanwhile an epidemic (~44% over 2 phases / reshuffle) hitting Baghdad fires 1 outbreak later under Share.

Trade: 6-action yellow acceleration + Santiago/keeping-window alive NOW vs. Baghdad defuse one player-turn sooner (and I can't feed his ride fully anyway with only 4 actions and my share needing 3!).

Can I hybridize? Spend: shareGive sequence (3 actions: Bogota, BA, shareGive) + dispatcherMove bob→SP (1). Total 4. ✔ This is exactly bob's "veto freely" clause — he offered default ride knowing veto freedom, and the yellow-share is what BOTH frontiers price higher (the exchange math: 7-action gap). His ride rationale mentioned "your later yellow deliverable converges with my black sweep for free" via Cairo-Khartoum proximity — giving BA now doesn't conflict with that at all; it COMPLETES the yellow pipeline into him. He asked for the ride as default but explicitly invited veto; CONFLICT RULE says name the deviation publicly. I'll send_message explaining: rode you 1 step (BA→Sao Paulo... wait careful: my shareGive requires US BOTH IN Buenos Aires. I drive to BA; he's ALREADY in BA. shareGive BA-card to him ✓. THEN dispatcherMove him BA→Sao Paulo. Net: he skips 1 step of his bridge, keeping exact total arrival (Baghdad end of his turn: SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad = 4 actions — perfect fit!). Everything preserved: yellows advanced 6 actions, black sweep UNDELAYED. 

Card check on shareGive: Share Knowledge give — I'm Researcher? NO I'm Dispatcher. Regular share rule: card must match the city we BOTH stand in. We both stand in Buenos Aires, card = Buenos Aires ✓ legal.

Risk on walking: Miami→Bogota→BA both cube-free (Mexico City 0, Bogota 0, BA 0 after bob's wipe ✓). Tonight's infection will flip rate-2 fresh cities — some new fire will sprout somewhere; acceptable, board-wide no 3s pending except Baghdad.

Hand limit: I stay at 6 after giving BA → 5. Fine.

Epidemic consideration for my draw: 45 cards, ~1 epidemic out there (4 epics among 45 unknown? standard 4 epidemic; discard empty so none drawn yet — 4 epidemics lurk among 45). My draw-risk preview optional; the referee summary gives P(epidemic)≈44% over next 2 phases. Nothing actionable beyond continuing clears — Forecast/OQN absent from hands.

Plan sequence (ordered actions):
1. driveFerry Miami→Bogota
2. driveFerry Bogota→Buenos Aires
3. shareGive Buenos Aires to bob
4. dispatcherMove bob São Paulo

Verify each legal given predecessors: after action 3, bob's menu includes driveFerry to Sao Paulo (from BA, SP adjacent ✓ and it's MY action spending his move — dispatcherMove driveFerry bob→SP: requires alice/bob adjacency logic = bob at BA, SP neighbor ✓ legal while turnOwner=me).

Then message + submit. Also should I pin_plan update? Standing pin says "alice owns AMERICAS+yellows: Miami→Bogota corridor, defuse Buenos Aires" — DONE now (bob wiped it); plan largely superseded events: BA/Madrid defused, bob owns Europe-blues done→blacks ahead of schedule, yellow cure logistics converging to bob. Update pin: NEW: bob = black sweep (Baghdad t_next, Riyadh/Karachi/Mumbai follow) + yellow collector (holds Kinshasa/Jo'burg/BA after tonight; needs Khartoum+Santiago; rendezvous Khartoum planned coincidental with his Africa/ME sweep, ping-ahead protocol); alice = dispatcher support, drift east toward Asia/red (hold Shanghai, HKG-side coverage, Mumbai 2-black watch), keeps black set for her cure; team targets: yellow cure ASAP then black; bombs remaining: Baghdad only until cleared. Keep it tight.

Actually also frontier alternative worth weighing quickly — the SA STATION idea ("build station at BA saves ~6 actions on cure runs"): bob holds BA after my share + could build station on HIS turn (needs discarding BA card — KILLS the yellow card! No.) Government Grant absent. Skip.

Preview_plan? The guidance: preview rival plans of different kinds when choice isn't forced. Choice here is between my share-line and his ride-line (both movement/sharing families, but meaningfully different). I've computed both manually against frontier pricing which already includes the key rivals (share line priced by system; Baghdad-drive line for ME — dominated since bob covers black nearer). A quick mechanical verification of MY 4-action sequence is cheap and catches illegal-step errors (e.g., shareGive ordering, dispatcherMove legality). Do ONE preview of the actual intended line. The doc mandates comparing two rival plans of DIFFERENT KINDS before submitting when "choice is not forced" — my alternatives genuinely compared: (A) share+assist (kind: share/move combo), (B) full ride chain (kind: pure dispatch-move). I'll preview both to honor the comparison duty, they're short plans.

Plan B detailed: dispatcherMove bob BA→SP; dispatcherMove bob SP→Madrid; dispatcherMove bob Madrid→Algiers; dispatcherMove bob Algiers→Cairo. That's the max-ride variant (arrives Cairo; he then drives→Baghdad himself action 1 of his turn and treats turn after... slightly worse than his stated wish of ending ADJACENT both — his ask literally ends Cairo too: "Ends me adjacent to BOTH Baghdad and Riyadh" ✓ matches: from Cairo both are adjacent; his next turn Cairo→Baghdad+treat as FIRST TWO actions ⇒ Baghdad clear DURING his next turn, before next-next infect. Under Plan A, bob self-drives full bridge ending ON Baghdad same turn-count → clear also completes during his next turn (treat as 1st action of the following one? no—wait).

Let me lay precise timelines.
After MY 4 actions:
Plan A: bob@SaoPaulo, I gave BA. His next turn 4 actions: SP→Madrid(1)→Algiers(2)→Cairo(3)→Baghdad(4). Turn ends IN Baghdad. Infection fires. Next turn: treat-black wipes 3 (+Riyadh trip +wipe, etc.). Baghdad defused mid-(t+2) counting my turn as t.
Plan B: bob@Cairo. His next turn: Cairo→Baghdad(1)+treat all-3(2)+spare moves toward Riyadh(3,4: Baghdad→Riyadh+... wait treating Riyadh from Baghdad? He drives Baghdad→Riyadh (3) then treat Riyadh's 1 (4)). Baghdad defused EARLIER (during t+1, before the infection phase of t+1!). Delta: Plan B beats A by exactly one infection-phase exposure for Baghdad IF the reshuffle/epidemic lands within that window (~44%/2phases → single-phase ~25%).

Plan A wins: +6 yellow-cure actions (system-priced), yellow hold-window secured, and Baghdad deferral costs ≤1 extra exposure-phase at 8-outbreak-margin 0/8. ALSO Plan A's SP-start actually lets him keep a spare action? No — 4 steps consume all 4. Equal.

Hybrid C?: skip Bogota-walk; directFlight-me somewhere + ride bob 3 steps? E.g., don't share BA... loses the whole point. No.

One more wrinkle: is riding bob SP now even NECESSARY? Without it (share only, 3 actions + 1 wasted/idle?) I'd have a 4th action needing purpose: options: dispatcherJump? me→bob (pointless), drive myself Bogota direction... Actually alternative 4th action: NONE useful at Miami. So SP-assist it is. Alternatively action 4: dispatcherMove bob→SP preserves his 4-action bridge = REQUIRED to fit exactly. Yes.

Edge: after shareGive, bob has 7 cards?! Bob currently 6 (Kinshasa, Bangkok, SF, Johannesburg, Tokyo, Madrid) + my BA = 7 = AT limit, fine (limit 7: "discard down if OVER"). He draws 2 next turn → 9 → must discard 2. Flag to bob: his post-draw discards should be FUEL-spends (Madrid already planned kept... he said "Madrid kept per blueprint"—as cure-set blue? blueprint assigns blue collection to bob: SF+Madrid = 2/5 blue ✓ consistent). Warn: incoming draw overflow → recommend discarding/spending Bangkok/Tokyo as flights rather than yellow/blue set cards. Mention in message.

Preview calls: Plan A = [driveFerry Bogota, driveFerry Buenos Aires, shareGive BA→bob, dispatcherMove bob driveFerry SP]. Plan B = 4×dispatcherMove ride BA→SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo. Run both in one block (independent), read outputs, then send_message (conflict notice + warnings), pin_plan refresh, submit_action #1 sequentially afterward.

Message content (concise): vetoed default-ride partially per your 'veto freely': chose yellow-share line — I walk into BA, hand you Buenos Aires card (you're standing on it — free rendezvous), then rode YOU BA→Sao Paulo so YOUR bridge fits exactly 4 self-steps to Baghdad same ETA. Rationale per frontier exchange: share line gains 6 cure-actions vs pure-ride; Baghdad ETA unchanged (you end your next turn IN Baghdad, wipe at dawn after — ≤1 extra exposure phase vs ride-now, acceptable at 0/8). Heads-up: BA puts you at 7 → you'll discard 2 after drawing; suggest burning Bangkok/Tokyo as flight fuel, protect blue/yellow sets. Also: your station idea at BA died since building burns the BA card — Grant-less no. 

Pin_plan text update (supersedes): STATUS: Madrid✓defused BA✓defused by bob turn; yellow 5/5 mapped (bob 3 after tonight incl BA, alice 2: Khartoum+Santiago). PLAN: bob continues black bridge SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad this turn (self-drive), treat-wipe Baghdad + Riyadh next turn; then Karachi/Mumbai residual per pressure. alice: guard watch Miami→east drift toward Asia next turns, hold Shanghai+black trio, ping-me-ahead protocol for Khartoum handoff during bob's Cairo↔Kinshasa arc (coincidental slot). Cures: yellow target next (converge cards to bob, cure at Atlanta after his MiddleEast leg), blue to bob slow-collect (SF+Madrid held), black to alice (keep trio), red to alice (Shanghai mine; bob's Bangkok/Tokyo = fuel). Remaining bomb: Baghdad only.

Now write tool calls. First the two previews (one block, independent).
```

text:

```text
State change: bob's own turn already wiped Madrid's blues and BA's yellows (both bombs dead — supplies confirm +2 blue, +3 yellow). Only Baghdad remains as a live 3⚠ bomb. He asks me to ride him BA→Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo, but he's sitting ON Buenos Aires where I can hand him the BA card this instant — a rendezvous that never repeats once he crosses to Spain. Comparing the two rival lines mechanically before committing:
```

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "preview_plan", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"plan": [{"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "shareGive", "to": "bob", "card": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}]}, "output": {"available": true, "preview": {"steps": [{"index": 0, "action": {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, "legalAfter": [{"tag": "pass"}, {"tag": "endActions"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Miami"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Mexico City"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Lima"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Khartoum"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Riyadh"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Karachi"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Santiago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "alice", "toPawn": "bob"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "bob", "toPawn": "alice"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Kinshasa"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Bangkok"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "San Francisco"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Johannesburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Tokyo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Madrid"}]}, {"index": 1, "action": {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, "legalAfter": "  {\"tag\":\"pass\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"endActions\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"driveFerry\",\"to\":\"Bogota\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"driveFerry\",\"to\":\"Sao Paulo\"}\n  directFlight — 5 options; build {\"tag\":\"directFlight\",\"to\":<one to below>}\n      to: \"Shanghai\", \"Khartoum\", \"Riyadh\", \"Karachi\", \"Santiago\"\n  charterFlight — 47 options; build {\"tag\":\"charterFlight\",\"to\":<one to below>}\n      to: \"San Francisco\", \"Chicago\", \"Toronto\", \"Atlanta\", \"Washington\", \"New York\", \"London\", \"Madrid\", \"Paris\", \"Essen\", \"Milan\", \"St. Petersburg\", \"Los Angeles\", \"Mexico City\", \"Miami\", \"Bogota\", \"Lima\", \"Santiago\", \"Sao Paulo\", \"Lagos\", \"Kinshasa\", \"Johannesburg\", \"Khartoum\", \"Algiers\", \"Cairo\", \"Istanbul\", \"Moscow\", \"Tehran\", \"Baghdad\", \"Riyadh\", \"Karachi\", \"Mumbai\", \"Delhi\", \"Kolkata\", \"Chennai\", \"Beijing\", \"Shanghai\", \"Seoul\", \"Tokyo\", \"Osaka\", \"Taipei\", \"Hong Kong\", \"Bangkok\", \"Ho Chi Minh City\", \"Manila\", \"Jakarta\", \"Sydney\"\n  {\"tag\":\"buildStation\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"shareGive\",\"to\":\"bob\",\"card\":\"Buenos Aires\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"driveFerry\",\"to\":\"Bogota\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"driveFerry\",\"to\":\"Sao Paulo\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"directFlight\",\"to\":\"Kinshasa\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"directFlight\",\"to\":\"Bangkok\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"directFlight\",\"to\":\"San Francisco\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"directFlight\",\"to\":\"Johannesburg\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"directFlight\",\"to\":\"Tokyo\"}\n  {\"tag\":\"dispatcherMove\",\"pawn\":\"bob\",\"via\":\"directFlight\",\"to\":\"Madrid\"}"}, {"index": 2, "action": {"tag": "shareGive", "to": "bob", "card": "Buenos Aires"}, "legalAfter": [{"tag": "pass"}, {"tag": "endActions"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Khartoum"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Riyadh"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Karachi"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Santiago"}, {"tag": "shareTake", "from": "bob", "card": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Kinshasa"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Bangkok"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "San Francisco"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Johannesburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Tokyo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Madrid"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "San Francisco"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Chicago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Toronto"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Atlanta"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Washington"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "New York"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "London"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Madrid"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Paris"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Essen"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Milan"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "St. Petersburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Los Angeles"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Mexico City"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Miami"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Lima"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Santiago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Lagos"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Kinshasa"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Johannesburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Khartoum"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Algiers"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Cairo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Istanbul"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Moscow"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Tehran"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Baghdad"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Riyadh"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Karachi"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Mumbai"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Delhi"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Kolkata"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Chennai"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Beijing"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Seoul"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Tokyo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Osaka"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Taipei"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Hong Kong"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Bangkok"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Ho Chi Minh City"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Manila"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Jakarta"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Sydney"}]}, {"index": 3, "action": {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, "legalAfter": []}], "diff": {"cubes": [], "moves": [{"player": "alice", "from": "Miami", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"player": "bob", "from": "Buenos Aires", "to": "Sao Paulo"}], "hands": [{"player": "alice", "spent": ["Buenos Aires"], "gained": []}, {"player": "bob", "spent": [], "gained": ["Buenos Aires"]}], "stationsBuilt": [], "stationsRemoved": [], "curesDiscovered": [], "actionsBefore": 4, "actionsAfter": 0, "outbreaksBefore": 0, "outbreaksAfter": 0}, "unexplored": [{"tag": "directFlight", "count": 6, "example": {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "count": 2, "example": {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "alice", "toPawn": "bob"}}], "boundary": {"kind": "turnComplete"}, "risk": {"playerDraw": {"cardsDrawn": 2, "remainingEpidemics": 4, "deckSize": 45, "lossOnDraw": false, "pAtLeastOneEpidemic": 0.2222222222222222, "epidemicOutbreakCandidates": []}, "infect": {"drawCount": 2, "undiscardedCount": 35, "perCityHitProbability": 0.05714285714285714, "threats": [{"city": "Baghdad", "color": "black", "currentCubes": 3, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": true, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}, {"city": "Essen", "color": "blue", "currentCubes": 2, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": false, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}, {"city": "Mumbai", "color": "black", "currentCubes": 2, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": false, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}, {"city": "St. Petersburg", "color": "blue", "currentCubes": 2, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": false, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}]}, "handLimit": {"viewer": "alice", "currentHandSize": 5, "handLimit": 7, "wouldExceed": false}, "cureFeasibility": [{"color": "blue", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}, {"color": "yellow", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}, {"color": "black", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}, {"color": "red", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}]}}}}
{"tool": "preview_plan", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"plan": [{"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Madrid"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Algiers"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Cairo"}]}, "output": {"available": true, "preview": {"steps": [{"index": 0, "action": {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, "legalAfter": [{"tag": "pass"}, {"tag": "endActions"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Atlanta"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Washington"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Mexico City"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Khartoum"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Riyadh"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Karachi"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Santiago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "alice", "toPawn": "bob"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "bob", "toPawn": "alice"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Madrid"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Lagos"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Kinshasa"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Bangkok"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "San Francisco"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Johannesburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Tokyo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Madrid"}]}, {"index": 1, "action": {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Madrid"}, "legalAfter": [{"tag": "pass"}, {"tag": "endActions"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Atlanta"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Washington"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Mexico City"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Khartoum"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Riyadh"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Karachi"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Santiago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "alice", "toPawn": "bob"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "bob", "toPawn": "alice"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "London"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "New York"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Paris"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Algiers"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Kinshasa"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Bangkok"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "San Francisco"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Johannesburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Tokyo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "San Francisco"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Chicago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Toronto"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Atlanta"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Washington"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "New York"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "London"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Paris"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Essen"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Milan"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "St. Petersburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Los Angeles"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Mexico City"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Miami"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Lima"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Santiago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Sao Paulo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Lagos"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Kinshasa"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Johannesburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Khartoum"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Algiers"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Cairo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Istanbul"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Moscow"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Tehran"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Baghdad"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Riyadh"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Karachi"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Mumbai"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Delhi"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Kolkata"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Chennai"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Beijing"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Seoul"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Tokyo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Osaka"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Taipei"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Hong Kong"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Bangkok"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Ho Chi Minh City"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Manila"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Jakarta"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "charterFlight", "to": "Sydney"}]}, {"index": 2, "action": {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Algiers"}, "legalAfter": [{"tag": "pass"}, {"tag": "endActions"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Atlanta"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Washington"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Mexico City"}, {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Khartoum"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Riyadh"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Karachi"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Buenos Aires"}, {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Santiago"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "alice", "toPawn": "bob"}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "bob", "toPawn": "alice"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Madrid"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Paris"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Cairo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Istanbul"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Kinshasa"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Bangkok"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "San Francisco"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Johannesburg"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Tokyo"}, {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "directFlight", "to": "Madrid"}]}, {"index": 3, "action": {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Cairo"}, "legalAfter": []}], "diff": {"cubes": [], "moves": [{"player": "bob", "from": "Buenos Aires", "to": "Cairo"}], "hands": [], "stationsBuilt": [], "stationsRemoved": [], "curesDiscovered": [], "actionsBefore": 4, "actionsAfter": 0, "outbreaksBefore": 0, "outbreaksAfter": 0}, "unexplored": [{"tag": "driveFerry", "count": 4, "example": {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Atlanta"}}, {"tag": "directFlight", "count": 6, "example": {"tag": "directFlight", "to": "Shanghai"}}, {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "count": 2, "example": {"tag": "dispatcherJump", "pawn": "alice", "toPawn": "bob"}}], "boundary": {"kind": "turnComplete"}, "risk": {"playerDraw": {"cardsDrawn": 2, "remainingEpidemics": 4, "deckSize": 45, "lossOnDraw": false, "pAtLeastOneEpidemic": 0.2222222222222222, "epidemicOutbreakCandidates": []}, "infect": {"drawCount": 2, "undiscardedCount": 35, "perCityHitProbability": 0.05714285714285714, "threats": [{"city": "Baghdad", "color": "black", "currentCubes": 3, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": true, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}, {"city": "Essen", "color": "blue", "currentCubes": 2, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": false, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}, {"city": "Mumbai", "color": "black", "currentCubes": 2, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": false, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}, {"city": "St. Petersburg", "color": "blue", "currentCubes": 2, "suppressedByQuarantine": false, "wouldOutbreak": false, "chainInto": [], "pHit": 0}]}, "handLimit": {"viewer": "alice", "currentHandSize": 6, "handLimit": 7, "wouldExceed": true}, "cureFeasibility": [{"color": "blue", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}, {"color": "yellow", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}, {"color": "black", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}, {"color": "red", "discarded": 0, "attainable": 12, "needed": 5, "curable": true}]}}}}
```

Step 2 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Both previews verified:

Plan A (share + assist): legal every step, ends bob@Sao Paulo, BA card to bob, my hand → 5 (Shanghai, Khartoum, Riyadh, Karachi, Santiago). Draw-phase: P(epidemic this draw) 22.2%, no outbreak candidates beyond Baghdad static risk; hand limit OK. Also note in Plan A's step-1 legalAfter: buildStation appeared at BA — but building burns nothing? buildStation discards the CURRENT city card (BA) — kills the yellow card AND now moot.

Plan B (full ride): legal, ends bob@Cairo, but hand-limit flag "wouldExceed: true" for alice at 6→8 after draws — I hold 6 and would discard down: that's a real cost of NOT giving BA away (keeping 6 cards → next turn I'm over-7 discipline drain). Another point for Plan A.

Also Plan A leaves bob exactly one step into his bridge (SP), preserving his 4-step self-drive to Baghdad with treats... wait Plan A bob@SP end of MY turn; HIS turn: SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad = 4 drives, arrives Baghdad end of his turn, treats next-turn-open. vs original ride-to-Cairo plan had him 2 actions from wipe too... The wipe timing differs by ≤1 infect phase; accept.

One more option visible in preview step-3 legalAfter of plan B... not needed.

Also noteworthy from preview risk: pAtLeastOneEpidemic on MY draw = 22%. If epidemic fires during my draw phase: infected city = bottom card re-surfaces etc., reshuffle puts Baghdad back on top... Baghdad wouldOutbreak:true if hit (it's not hit by infections unless epidemic-injected). Resilient Population/Forecast absent. Can't mitigate further this turn; proceed.

Now execute Plan A actions sequentially (must be one-at-a-time since each changes legality): message first (conflict notice), then pin update, then action 1. Message + pin are independent — batch them together. Then submit driveFerry Bogota.
```

text:

```text
Both lines verified legal. Verdict: **Plan A (yellow share + 1-step assist)** beats the full ride — it banks the system-priced 6-action yellow-cure acceleration *and* fixes a second problem the ride didn't even know it had: keeping 6 cards means my next draw overflows the hand limit (preview flagged `wouldExceed:true`); sharing drops me to 5 and hands bob a free rendezvous he's standing on. His bridge still lands him IN Baghdad by end of his own turn — same ETA, zero black delay. Announcing the veto per conflict rule, refreshing the pin:
```

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "send_message", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"text": "Vetoed your default ride — 'veto freely' clause invoked, here's why: you're standing ON Buenos Aires, so I walk Miami→Bogota→BA (2) + hand you the BA card NOW (1) = the frontier's biggest prize (+6 cure-actions, yellow 5/5 fully mapped, window that dies the moment you cross to Spain). Action 4 rides YOU BA→Sao Paulo — your bridge still fits EXACTLY: SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad self-drive all 4 steps, arrive Baghdad end of your turn, medic-wipe opens next turn. Black ETA unchanged; cost is only ~one extra exposure phase for Baghdad at 0/8 margin (~22% epidemic/draw). Two notes: (1) BA puts you at 7 cards — after your next draw you overflow; burn Bangkok/Tokyo as flight fuel, protect blue+yellow sets. (2) Your station-at-BA idea is dead unless Grant shows up: buildStation burns the BA card. Otherwise executing your blueprint as written."}, "output": {"sent": true, "note": "You have sent 1 of 5 messages available this turn."}}
{"tool": "pin_plan", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"text": "PLAN v2 (supersedes v1; Madrid+BA already defused by bob's turn). CURES: yellow NEXT TARGET — all 5 cards mapped: bob holds Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA(tonight), alice holds Khartoum+Santiago; converge into BOB. Handoff protocol: when bob's Africa/MiddleEast sweep comes within 1-2 steps of Khartoum, bob pings alice ONE TURN AHEAD ('K-chart') and alice flies Khartoum-card herself INTO the meet-city = coincidental slot. Santiago: discuss after yellow count reaches 4. BLUE: bob slow-collects (SF+Madrid held, 2/5; Essen/StP cluster dormant 2s). BLACK: alice collects (Riyadh+Karachi kept; needs 3 more draws — Mumbai/Kolkata/Moscow/Cairo watch). RED: alice keeps Shanghai; bob burns Bangkok/Tokyo as fuel. REGION/TEMPO: bob = black bridge SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad THIS turn (self-drive, arrive end-of-turn), wipe-all Baghdad + Riyadh t+1; then Karachi/Mumbai per supply pressure. alice = dispatcher assist rides each round + drift east toward Asia/red next turns. ONLY remaining 3⚠ bomb: Baghdad until wiped."}, "output": {"pinned": true, "note": "This replaces the standing team plan; both players will see it every turn until superseded. You have sent 2 of 5 messages available this turn."}}
```

Step 3 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning: null

text: ""

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "submit_action", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"action": {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}}, "output": {"submitted": true, "action": {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Bogota"}}}
```

### alice-legacy-p0011 {#d-alice-legacy-p0011}

Seat: alice. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 11. Active turn: True.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/alice-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/alice-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

- [Event #23](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e23) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

None recorded.

**Recorded input**

```text
ACTIVE TURN — it is your move.

STANDING TEAM PLAN (alice, pinned this turn):
  PLAN v2 (supersedes v1; Madrid+BA already defused by bob's turn). CURES: yellow NEXT TARGET — all 5 cards mapped: bob holds Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA(tonight), alice holds Khartoum+Santiago; converge into BOB. Handoff protocol: when bob's Africa/MiddleEast sweep comes within 1-2 steps of Khartoum, bob pings alice ONE TURN AHEAD ('K-chart') and alice flies Khartoum-card herself INTO the meet-city = coincidental slot. Santiago: discuss after yellow count reaches 4. BLUE: bob slow-collects (SF+Madrid held, 2/5; Essen/StP cluster dormant 2s). BLACK: alice collects (Riyadh+Karachi kept; needs 3 more draws — Mumbai/Kolkata/Moscow/Cairo watch). RED: alice keeps Shanghai; bob burns Bangkok/Tokyo as fuel. REGION/TEMPO: bob = black bridge SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad THIS turn (self-drive, arrive end-of-turn), wipe-all Baghdad + Riyadh t+1; then Karachi/Mumbai per supply pressure. alice = dispatcher assist rides each round + drift east toward Asia/red next turns. ONLY remaining 3⚠ bomb: Baghdad until wiped.
If the board has invalidated this plan or it is complete, replace it via
pin_plan — until then, your partner is assuming you are following it.
CONFLICT RULE: when your own read of the board — a signal, the DECISION
FRONTIER, a preview result — argues against this plan, do NOT silently
obey and do NOT silently deviate. CALL send_message naming the conflict
(the city and what you would do instead), then resolve it: your partner's
reply or a fresh pin_plan. A stale pin never outranks the live board.

ACTION ECONOMY: you have 2 action(s) left this turn against 1 city(ies) at 3 cubes and 3 at 2. Unused actions are lost forever — passing or ending your turn now spends your scarcest resource (4/turn) on nothing. Unless you are a Quarantine Specialist holding a shield over a hot cluster, spend it: treat, or move toward the nearest hot city. A pointless move away and back is not action economy.

TRIAGE: the DECISION FRONTIER below prices this turn's rival plans
against each other. Pick a line, extend it, or beat it with your own
plan via preview_plan; split targets with teammates either way.

=== STATE ===
phase=playerActions turnOwner=alice  (actions left: 2)
you=alice role=dispatcher at=Buenos Aires
cures: blue:none yellow:none black:none red:none  outbreaks=0/8  infectionRate=2
stations: Atlanta
players: alice@Buenos Aires(dispatcher) hand=6 [Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Buenos Aires(yellow), Santiago(yellow)]  bob@Buenos Aires(medic) hand=6 [Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue)]
supply: blue:18 yellow:24 black:15 red:23   decks: player=45 infection=35   player-discard: —
threats (cube counts, cluster membership, supply pressure, route cost from you, infect-discard — one row per city):
  Baghdad: 3 black⚠ [in infect-discard] — 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad
  Essen: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 4 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen
  Mumbai: 2 black [in infect-discard] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 7 move(s): Bogota→Mexico City→Los Angeles→Sydney→Jakarta→Chennai→Mumbai
  St. Petersburg: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen→St. Petersburg
  Riyadh: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Ho Chi Minh City: 1 red [in infect-discard]
  Kolkata: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Moscow: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  New York: 1 blue [in infect-discard]
  Karachi: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Toronto: 1 blue [in infect-discard]

=== SIGNALS ===
deck clock: 45 cards → 22 player-turn(s) of draws left; 4 cure(s) still needed → one cure every ~5 turn(s), team-wide
eradication: none in reach
DISPATCHER REACH (your turn moves ANY pawn — jump one onto a teammate's city for 1 action at any distance, or drive it 1 city/action; both card-free):
  Baghdad(black): drive alice 5 step(s) to Baghdad → then that pawn treats
cure plan — TEAM-WIDE collector assignment (cures WIN the game; treating only buys time):
  blue: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your blue cards when you share
  yellow: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your yellow cards when you share
  black: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY black card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  red: YOU collect (1/5) — keep EVERY red card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  share now available: alice should GIVE Buenos Aires to bob (the yellow collector). One direction only — never trade it back.
share rendezvous — TEAM-WIDE transfer routes (cards in the wrong hand + where to meet):
  hand Khartoum(yellow) to bob: meet IN Khartoum (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +5 move(s) to cure
  hand Santiago(yellow) to bob: meet IN Santiago (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure
  bob hands you Tokyo(red): meet IN Tokyo (the card's own city) — you 5 move(s), bob 5 move(s); then alice to station Atlanta +3 move(s) to cure
station opportunities (stations enable cures and shuttle travel):
  you hold Khartoum, 3 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 5 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~0 action(s) on current cure runs) — costs Khartoum(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Khartoum 5→0, Johannesburg 6→1, Kinshasa 5→1, Cairo 5→1; board-wide: 18 cities closer, 55 trip-actions shaved
  you are AT Buenos Aires holding its card — buildStation NOW (nearest station is 3 moves away; saves ~12 action(s) on remaining cure runs: blue 3→0, yellow 3→0, black 3→0, red 3→0) — costs Buenos Aires(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Buenos Aires 3→0, Sao Paulo 3→1, Lagos 4→2, Kinshasa 5→3; board-wide: 20 cities closer, 27 trip-actions shaved

⚠ DECISION FRONTIER — 2 rival turn-plan(s); NONE dominates another.
NOT a ranking — a curve between the two ways to lose. DOWN trades cure-pipeline
actions for fewer expected outbreaks; UP reverses it. No line is best: pick the
end facing whichever clock is closer to killing you.
  clocks — outbreaks 0/8; deck ~22 turn(s), 4 cure(s) still needed
Priced nominees, not orders — pick one, extend it, or beat it via preview_plan.
  - advance the yellow cure: hand off a card at Buenos Aires (bob collects, 3 still needed) — shareGive
     tempo: 3 action(s) closer to the yellow cure (25 → 22 action(s) to land it) — bob collects | risk after: ~0.0 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases + 1 armed discard bomb(s) (Baghdad): P(epidemic in window) ≈ 44%, and the reshuffle re-arms them ALL — ~1 chained outbreak(s) committed over the ~7 infect phase(s) after it, cancelable ONLY by treating them before it fires
  - break the Essen–St. Petersburg blue cluster at Essen — drive Sao Paulo, drive Madrid
     tempo: 1 action(s) further from the red cure (64 → 65 action(s) to land it) — you collect | risk after: ~0.0 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases + 1 armed discard bomb(s) (Baghdad): P(epidemic in window) ≈ 44%, and the reshuffle re-arms them ALL — ~1 chained outbreak(s) committed over the ~7 infect phase(s) after it, cancelable ONLY by treating them before it fires; en route to clear blue at Essen — worth ~2 cube(s)+chain when finished, but the clear lands AFTER this window: the next 2 infect phases face the board as-is
  exchange "advance the yellow cure: hand off a card at Bue…" → "break the Essen–St. Petersburg blue cluster at …": gives up 4 action(s) of cure progress to move risk ~0.0 expected outbreaks → ~0.0
  SPLIT DECISION — this antichain holds a cure line AND a containment line
  and neither dominates: that is a TEAM call, not a solo one. Before you
  commit, CALL send_message with your pick and a one-line reason so your
  partner can veto or extend it — a silent choice here is how chains get
  missed.

Your legal actions — this is the COMPLETE legal set; anything not named
here will be rejected. A `[n] {...}` line is literal: pass it verbatim to
submit_action.action. A grouped family gives a template plus the values
allowed in it: fill the template with one combination shown on a single
line and pass that.
  [0] {"tag":"pass"}
  [1] {"tag":"endActions"}
  [2] {"tag":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [3] {"tag":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  directFlight — 5 options; build {"tag":"directFlight","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Shanghai", "Khartoum", "Riyadh", "Karachi", "Santiago"
  charterFlight — 47 options; build {"tag":"charterFlight","to":<one to below>}
      to: "San Francisco", "Chicago", "Toronto", "Atlanta", "Washington", "New York", "London", "Madrid", "Paris", "Essen", "Milan", "St. Petersburg", "Los Angeles", "Mexico City", "Miami", "Bogota", "Lima", "Santiago", "Sao Paulo", "Lagos", "Kinshasa", "Johannesburg", "Khartoum", "Algiers", "Cairo", "Istanbul", "Moscow", "Tehran", "Baghdad", "Riyadh", "Karachi", "Mumbai", "Delhi", "Kolkata", "Chennai", "Beijing", "Shanghai", "Seoul", "Tokyo", "Osaka", "Taipei", "Hong Kong", "Bangkok", "Ho Chi Minh City", "Manila", "Jakarta", "Sydney"
  [56] {"tag":"buildStation"}
  [57] {"tag":"shareGive","to":"bob","card":"Buenos Aires"}
  [58] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [59] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  [60] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Kinshasa"}
  [61] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Bangkok"}
  [62] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"San Francisco"}
  [63] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Johannesburg"}
  [64] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Tokyo"}
  [65] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Madrid"}
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

Step 1 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Two actions left. Plan: shareGive BA to bob (action 3), then dispatcherMove bob → Sao Paulo (action 4). Bob ends turn at SP (7 cards, he discards fuel during his draw phase or keeps per his judgement — actually hand limit forces him to discard at end of HIS action phase before drawing? Hand limit check: "Draw 2 player cards into your hand... Hand limit is 7; discard down if over." So limit applies after drawing; with 7 already he'll be at 9 and must drop to 7 — burns 2 fuel cards e.g., Bangkok+Tokyo. That's his call; I've flagged it twice.) Then I endActions? No — my actions all spent: share (1), ride (1) = 2 used, 0 left of my 4 total this turn (I'd used drive Bogota + drive BA earlier: 2+2 = 4 ✓). So submit share now, then the bob→SP move next prompt.

Frontier note: station-at-BA opportunity — buildStation at Buenos Aires "saves ~12 actions" BUT costs the BA card which is the yellow cure collector's needed card... conflict! The signal says "costs Buenos Aires(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable". Yellow margin: yellow supply 24, board yellows minimal — the card would leave play though, meaning yellow cure can NEVER complete with only 5 mapped cards?! Wait — "you hold Buenos Aires" burnable logic assumes 7 yellow still in deck for re-draws. All 5 live yellows are mapped; burning BA means bob can never have 5 yellow city cards unless a 6th... there are exactly 12 yellow cities; in-deck: 45-card player deck holds most city cards. Hands hold 5 yellows currently (12-5=7 more in deck+discard=none yet... deck 45 includes ~30ish city cards + 4 epidemic + events?). Events 5 among them. Anyway burning BA = rely on redrawing it later for the cure set. That delays yellow cure by redrawing luck (~7 in deck / 45 ≈ 15.6% per draw pair?? roughly one every ~6 turns worst case). The yellow-cure plan (tempo 25 actions) would inflate badly. REJECT buildStation; the "~12 actions saved" pricing ignores destroying the mapped cure card. Also SOP: stations never relaxed sharing, but station SP/BA helps future cures... The cost side wins: keep BA alive. Message bob briefly? My earlier message covered protecting sets. Frontier doesn't even list buildStation as nominee. Skip message (2/5 used), just execute shares/moves.

Action: shareGive now.
```

text: ""

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "submit_action", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"action": {"tag": "shareGive", "to": "bob", "card": "Buenos Aires"}}, "output": {"submitted": true, "action": {"tag": "shareGive", "to": "bob", "card": "Buenos Aires"}}}
```

### alice-legacy-p0013 {#d-alice-legacy-p0013}

Seat: alice. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 13. Active turn: True.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/alice-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/alice-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

- [Event #25](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e25) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join
- [Event #26](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e26) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

```json
{"kind": "supersede", "hit": true}
```

**Recorded input**

```text
POOL MESSAGE from bob (event #24): Veto ACCEPTED — your line is strictly better: Miami→Bogota→BA walk, give me BA(yellow), ride me BA→Sao Paulo. Baghdad eats one exposure phase (~22%) at 0/8 margin — fine. THREE refinements: (1) YELLOW IS NOT CURABLE YET — after the give I hold 3/5 (Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA); Khartoum+Santiago still parked with you. Don't send anyone toward Atlanta on my behalf until I say "5 in hand": my activation trip comes from Cairo/Khartoum-side AFTER convergence, likely combined with a Get Grant/Khartoum handoff. (2) Card-protocol from Sao Paulo onward: absolute-protect = SF+Madrid(blue), all yellows incl BA (agreed: no station-burn without Grant); sacrifice order = Bangkok THEN Tokyo (recoverable via epidemic reshuffle; prefer handoff to you if we ever co-locate, else deliberate overflow-drop only when forced). (3) Next turn I self-drive all 4 steps SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad, arrive with wipes loaded; if I draw an epidemic en route I adapt the wipe order live and message you. Ride away.

ACTIVE TURN — it is your move.

STANDING TEAM PLAN (alice, pinned this turn):
  PLAN v2 (supersedes v1; Madrid+BA already defused by bob's turn). CURES: yellow NEXT TARGET — all 5 cards mapped: bob holds Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA(tonight), alice holds Khartoum+Santiago; converge into BOB. Handoff protocol: when bob's Africa/MiddleEast sweep comes within 1-2 steps of Khartoum, bob pings alice ONE TURN AHEAD ('K-chart') and alice flies Khartoum-card herself INTO the meet-city = coincidental slot. Santiago: discuss after yellow count reaches 4. BLUE: bob slow-collects (SF+Madrid held, 2/5; Essen/StP cluster dormant 2s). BLACK: alice collects (Riyadh+Karachi kept; needs 3 more draws — Mumbai/Kolkata/Moscow/Cairo watch). RED: alice keeps Shanghai; bob burns Bangkok/Tokyo as fuel. REGION/TEMPO: bob = black bridge SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad THIS turn (self-drive, arrive end-of-turn), wipe-all Baghdad + Riyadh t+1; then Karachi/Mumbai per supply pressure. alice = dispatcher assist rides each round + drift east toward Asia/red next turns. ONLY remaining 3⚠ bomb: Baghdad until wiped.
If the board has invalidated this plan or it is complete, replace it via
pin_plan — until then, your partner is assuming you are following it.
CONFLICT RULE: when your own read of the board — a signal, the DECISION
FRONTIER, a preview result — argues against this plan, do NOT silently
obey and do NOT silently deviate. CALL send_message naming the conflict
(the city and what you would do instead), then resolve it: your partner's
reply or a fresh pin_plan. A stale pin never outranks the live board.

ACTION ECONOMY: you have 1 action(s) left this turn against 1 city(ies) at 3 cubes and 3 at 2. Unused actions are lost forever — passing or ending your turn now spends your scarcest resource (4/turn) on nothing. Unless you are a Quarantine Specialist holding a shield over a hot cluster, spend it: treat, or move toward the nearest hot city. A pointless move away and back is not action economy.

TRIAGE: 1 city(ies) sit at 3 cubes — each infect phase can
turn one into an outbreak, and outbreaks are how games are lost. Spending
actions to defuse a 3-cube city (move there + treat, see containment
routes) usually beats aimless play. Split targets with teammates.
EXCEPTION — cures outrank triage: treating NEVER wins the game, four
cures do. If the cure plan says you have a full set, or you can complete
one this turn, go cure it even while cities burn. Containment is how you
survive; cures are how you win.

=== STATE ===
phase=playerActions turnOwner=alice  (actions left: 1)
you=alice role=dispatcher at=Buenos Aires
cures: blue:none yellow:none black:none red:none  outbreaks=0/8  infectionRate=2
stations: Atlanta
players: alice@Buenos Aires(dispatcher) hand=5 [Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Santiago(yellow)]  bob@Buenos Aires(medic) hand=7 [Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue), Buenos Aires(yellow)]
supply: blue:18 yellow:24 black:15 red:23   decks: player=45 infection=35   player-discard: —
threats (cube counts, cluster membership, supply pressure, route cost from you, infect-discard — one row per city):
  Baghdad: 3 black⚠ [in infect-discard] — 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad
  Essen: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 4 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen
  Mumbai: 2 black [in infect-discard] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 7 move(s): Bogota→Mexico City→Los Angeles→Sydney→Jakarta→Chennai→Mumbai
  St. Petersburg: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen→St. Petersburg
  Riyadh: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Ho Chi Minh City: 1 red [in infect-discard]
  Kolkata: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Moscow: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  New York: 1 blue [in infect-discard]
  Karachi: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Toronto: 1 blue [in infect-discard]

=== SIGNALS ===
deck clock: 45 cards → 22 player-turn(s) of draws left; 4 cure(s) still needed → one cure every ~5 turn(s), team-wide
eradication: none in reach
DISPATCHER REACH (your turn moves ANY pawn — jump one onto a teammate's city for 1 action at any distance, or drive it 1 city/action; both card-free):
  Baghdad(black): drive alice 5 step(s) to Baghdad → then that pawn treats
cure plan — TEAM-WIDE collector assignment (cures WIN the game; treating only buys time):
  blue: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your blue cards when you share
  yellow: bob collects (3/5) — give bob your yellow cards when you share
  black: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY black card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  red: YOU collect (1/5) — keep EVERY red card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
share rendezvous — TEAM-WIDE transfer routes (cards in the wrong hand + where to meet):
  hand Khartoum(yellow) to bob: meet IN Khartoum (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +5 move(s) to cure; HAND CAP: bob already has 7/7; the share forces an immediate discard — name the non-yellow card to shed before committing
  hand Santiago(yellow) to bob: meet IN Santiago (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure; HAND CAP: bob already has 7/7; the share forces an immediate discard — name the non-yellow card to shed before committing
  bob hands you Tokyo(red): meet IN Tokyo (the card's own city) — you 5 move(s), bob 5 move(s); then alice to station Atlanta +3 move(s) to cure
station opportunities (stations enable cures and shuttle travel):
  you hold Khartoum, 3 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 5 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~0 action(s) on current cure runs) — costs Khartoum(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Khartoum 5→0, Johannesburg 6→1, Kinshasa 5→1, Cairo 5→1; board-wide: 18 cities closer, 55 trip-actions shaved
  you hold Santiago, 3 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 4 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~0 action(s) on current cure runs) — costs Santiago(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Santiago 4→0, Lima 3→1; board-wide: 2 cities closer, 6 trip-actions shaved

Your legal actions — this is the COMPLETE legal set; anything not named
here will be rejected. A `[n] {...}` line is literal: pass it verbatim to
submit_action.action. A grouped family gives a template plus the values
allowed in it: fill the template with one combination shown on a single
line and pass that.
  [0] {"tag":"pass"}
  [1] {"tag":"endActions"}
  [2] {"tag":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [3] {"tag":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  directFlight — 5 options; build {"tag":"directFlight","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Shanghai", "Khartoum", "Riyadh", "Karachi", "Santiago"
  [9] {"tag":"shareTake","from":"bob","card":"Buenos Aires"}
  [10] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [11] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  [12] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Kinshasa"}
  [13] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Bangkok"}
  [14] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"San Francisco"}
  [15] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Johannesburg"}
  [16] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Tokyo"}
  [17] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Madrid"}
  [18] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"San Francisco"}
  [19] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Chicago"}
  [20] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Toronto"}
  [21] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Atlanta"}
  [22] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Washington"}
  [23] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"New York"}
  [24] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"London"}
  [25] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Madrid"}
  [26] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Paris"}
  [27] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Essen"}
  [28] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Milan"}
  [29] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"St. Petersburg"}
  [30] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Los Angeles"}
  [31] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Mexico City"}
  [32] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Miami"}
  [33] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Bogota"}
  [34] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Lima"}
  [35] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Santiago"}
  [36] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  [37] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Lagos"}
  [38] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Kinshasa"}
  [39] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Johannesburg"}
  [40] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Khartoum"}
  [41] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Algiers"}
  [42] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Cairo"}
  [43] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Istanbul"}
  [44] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Moscow"}
  [45] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Tehran"}
  [46] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Baghdad"}
  [47] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Riyadh"}
  [48] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Karachi"}
  [49] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Mumbai"}
  [50] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Delhi"}
  [51] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Kolkata"}
  [52] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Chennai"}
  [53] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Beijing"}
  [54] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Shanghai"}
  [55] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Seoul"}
  [56] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Tokyo"}
  [57] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Osaka"}
  [58] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Taipei"}
  [59] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Hong Kong"}
  [60] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Bangkok"}
  [61] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Ho Chi Minh City"}
  [62] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Manila"}
  [63] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Jakarta"}
  [64] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Sydney"}
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

Step 1 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Bob's message: veto accepted; ride away. He wants the last action to ride him BA→Sao Paulo. He's at 7 cards now (hand cap) — he said burn order Bangkok then Tokyo as sacrifice, but he self-drives next turn. My last action: dispatcherMove bob → Sao Paulo per agreement.

Wait — should I instead reconsider? His hand is 7/7 already. Next turn he draws 2 → 9, discards 2 (his own turn handles it). He'll keep blues + yellows, drop Bangkok/Tokyo or two others... Actually he holds: Kinshasa(y), Bangkok(r), SF(b), Johannesburg(y), Tokyo(r), Madrid(b), BA(y). After draw he'll have 9 and must discard 2 — likely Bangkok+Tokyo. But wait: those reds are his only flight fuel for a charter. If he drops both on his turn start... no wait, discard happens AFTER draw at end of his movement? Hand limit check: after drawing 2 at end of action phase. He can also spend them BEFORE drawing during his 4 actions (e.g., charter Bangkok→ somewhere, directFlight Tokyo). Hmm, actually — interesting option: I could charter-ride him via directFlight now (spending HIS card)! dispatcherMove bob via directFlight to Tokyo would spend his Tokyo card. But that's NOT what we agreed — agreed was BA→SP drive step 1, then he self-drives SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad.

Could I optimize: use THIS action to move him via "directFlight" SPENDING one of his sacrificial cards? E.g., dispatcherMove bob directFlight→Cairo (burns Cairo card)? He doesn't hold Cairo. Direct flights available in menu with his hand: Kinshasa, Bangkok, SF, Johannesburg, Tokyo, Madrid → destinations Kinshasa/Bangkok/SF/Johannesburg/Tokyo/Madrid. A direct flight burns DESTINATION card: dispatcherMove bob via directFlight to Madrid = burn Madrid(blue) ✗ protected. To Bangkok = burn Bangkok(red), putting him IN Bangkok — wrong continent vs bridge. To Tokyo — burns Tokyo, puts him Tokyo — no. So no direct flight helps the Baghdad mission without burning protected blue.

What about dispatcherMove bob via charterFlight to Cairo? That spends bob's CURRENT city card (BA — yellow, protected per protocol "absolute-protect all yellows"). He explicitly wants yellows kept. Even though it'd save 4 actions of self-driving (charter = 1 action lands him IN Cairo, adjacent to Baghdad!), burning BA yellow kills the yellow cure set we just built (BA back into discard; recoverable ONLY via reshuffle after another epidemic... actually once in player-discard it can't re-enter except nothing recovers player cards! Player cards never return from discard (no mechanic in base game except... none). Wait — Resilient Population only removes infection cards. Epidemic reshuffles INFECTION deck, not player deck. So a discarded yellow card = LOST forever from that cure run! CRITICAL: if 5th yellow gets burned, yellow becomes UNCURABLE (only 4 remain → needs 5). So absolutely NEVER burn BA/yellows/because then color uncurable. Bob's protect order is right and charter-from-BA would be catastrophic. Good thing it's not in play... though my legal menu DID offer [35] dispatcherMove bob charter Santiago etc. Never do those while holding yellows on his pawn.

Note menu item [46] dispatcherMove bob charterFlight Baghdad = burns HIS current-city card... current city BA → burns BA ✗ forbidden.

So: final action = drive him BA→Sao Paulo as agreed. Submit [11] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}.

Also consider: should I instead use last action for my OWN position? I'm at BA; next turn I want to drift toward east/Khartoum-side eventually for K-chart slot. Options from BA: drive Bogota (backtrack west ✗), drive Sao Paulo (toward Africa bridge side), directFlight Khartoum (burn Khartoum ✗ kill yellow!), directFlight Santiago (burn ✗), directFlight Riyadh (burn Riyadh black ✗ my black collect), directFlight Karachi (✗ same), directFlight Shanghai (burn Shanghai RED ✗ my red collect), charterFlight ANYWHERE burning BA... wait BA was given to bob; I no longer hold it. My hand: Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Santiago(yellow) = 5 cards. All four colors represented are CURE-critical: Shanghai=my only red, yellows=2 of remaining yellow set, blacks=half my black set. NOTHING in my hand is fuel. Any direct/charter costs me cure material — forbidden. So my positioning moves must be card-free drives. Drive Sao Paulo = 1 east-step toward Lagos→Khartoum corridor & keeps me near bob for future shares. That'd put me SP, bob SP... hmm but ride uses this action for BOB. Which is more valuable?

Ride bob →SP saves him 1 action next turn (bridge done in 3 not 4, giving him a spare treat/dead action buffer... actually medic wipe-all means Baghdad wipe = 1 action (all 3 at once cured-black auto), Riyadh 1, so spare actions exist anyway). Alternative: my own SP step moves ME toward K-chart rendezvous readiness (bob said meet-city comes from Cairo/Khartoum side ~his t+2; my being closer cuts my approach by 1-2).

Which single action matters more? Bob driving himself BA→SP next turn costs him exactly 1 of his 4 actions on a turn where wipes are cheap (Baghdad treat-all=1, Riyadh=1; he arrives Cairo EOT with 0 actions left either way — wait if he self-drives 4 steps SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad that's ALL 4 actions, arriving WITH ZERO actions left. The wipe happens t+1 morning. If I pre-move him to SP tonight, he spends 3 (Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad) arriving with 1 spare action which could TREAT nothing at Baghdad yet (arrive = treat possible same turn? Arrive action 4 AT Baghdad then no more actions. Hmm: 3 drives leaves 1 action — he arrives Baghdad ON the 4th? No: 3 drives = SP→Madrid(1)→Algiers(2)→Cairo(3); that ends him IN Cairo with 1 action left, cannot reach Baghdad. So ride saves nothing time-wise: he still reaches Baghdad end-of-turn in both cases; only difference = whether HE burns an action or I burn mine.

Trade pure action-for-action: either action moves SOMEONE to SP tonight. Whose action is worth more? Mine are dispatcher-moves (specialist synergy) AND bob's next turn has wipes worth doing early?? Medic wipe doesn't help mid-route cities (none infected en route except Baghdad itself). Equivalent.

But MY body reaching east sooner affects the YELLOW handoff latency later (K-chart fly-in requires me; being at SP vs BA when ping comes: SP is 1 closer). Also keeps me co-located ready to SHARE cards anytime (can't share across distance!). The real kicker: whoever goes to SP tonight, the OTHER goes tomorrow; net team displacement identical. Dispatcher rule of thumb: use MY action slots for pawns (chain-ride), spend BOB's slots on medic-specific work (treats). But there IS no treat work until Baghdad arrival...

Hmm — better micro-opt: give him the ride (he asked, zero downside, symmetric otherwise) and NEXT TURN dispatch him Chicago-style again if needed. Fine: execute [11] driver ride bob→Sao Paulo. It matches explicit request ("Ride away") — honoring teammate's named plan beats marginal symmetric swap.

Actually wait, one more consideration: if bob is IN Sao Paulo tonight, tonight's INFECT phase happens — does SP get infected? SP currently clean; infect flips fresh cards mostly (hotspots all in discard; fresh-only exposure ~2 draws). If SP gets hit while bob sits there, next infect of SAME city would matter little; plus outbreak risk irrelevant (fresh 1 cube). Either pawn absorbs equally. Symmetric confirmed.

Submit ride. Then brief ack message? Bob gave protocol refinements (protect lists). Nothing new requiring broadcast — plan v2 pin already covers protection; his refinements formalize it. Maybe send tiny ack confirming ride done + noting NO-share-to-bob-until-'5-in-hand' flag (important anti-drift constraint for ME next turns: don't fly Khartoum card until pinged). One-line ack with count state is useful since situation changed (yellow now 3/5 mapped-in-bob). Send short message + submit.
```

text: ""

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "send_message", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"text": "Protocol locked in: absolute-protect list honored (SF/Madrid/all yellows incl. freshly-given BA — and I'll add the hard edge for my own card discipline: a burned yellow/black/red set-card makes that cure ARITHMETICALLY dead in base rules since player cards never return from discard, so zero yellow burns even under pressure), sacrifice = Bangkok then Tokyo, brown-out only when overflow forces it. Confirming I will NOT advance any yellow trip toward Atlanta until you literally call '5 in hand' — Khartoum+Santiago stay parked with me until your K-chart ping. Executing the ride now: your pawn leaves Buenos Aires tonight, you self-drive the full 4-step bridge next turn. Good hunting in Baghdad."}, "output": {"sent": true, "note": "You have sent 3 of 5 messages available this turn."}}
{"tool": "submit_action", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"action": {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}}, "output": {"submitted": true, "action": {"tag": "dispatcherMove", "pawn": "bob", "via": "driveFerry", "to": "Sao Paulo"}}}
```

### bob-legacy-p0009 {#d-bob-legacy-p0009}

Seat: bob. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 9. Active turn: False.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/bob-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/bob-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

- [Event #17](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e17) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join
- [Event #18](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e18) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

None recorded.

**Recorded input**

```text
ADVISORY — alice is on the move; you cannot act.

STANDING TEAM PLAN (alice, pinned 1 of your turn(s) ago):
  REGIONS: bob(medic) owns EUROPE-blues→blacks: t+1 treat Madrid (chain-dropped there by alice), then Essen→StP → blue eradication target t+2-3, then sweep black via Istanbul/Cairo→Baghdad 3⚠. alice(dispatcher) owns AMERICAS+yellows: Miami→Bogota corridor, defuse Buenos Aires 3⚠ (~t+2-3, costs her 3 treats), feed own black/red sets. HANDS: alice keeps Khartoum/Riyadh/Karachi/Shanghai; bob keeps SF/Kinshasa/Johannesburg (cure sets), Bangkok red is fuel/handoff-to-alice. NO dedicated card-meet trips (Khartoum/Bangkok handoffs shelved unless coincidental, per bob). Bombs to watch in infect-discard: Baghdad, Buenos Aires, Essen/StP until cleared.
If the board has invalidated this plan or it is complete, replace it via
pin_plan — until then, your partner is assuming you are following it.
CONFLICT RULE: when your own read of the board — a signal, the DECISION
FRONTIER, a preview result — argues against this plan, do NOT silently
obey and do NOT silently deviate. CALL send_message naming the conflict
(the city and what you would do instead), then resolve it: your partner's
reply or a fresh pin_plan. A stale pin never outranks the live board.

=== STATE ===
phase=playerActions turnOwner=alice  (actions left: 4)
you=bob role=medic at=Buenos Aires
cures: blue:none yellow:none black:none red:none  outbreaks=0/8  infectionRate=2
stations: Atlanta
players: alice@Miami(dispatcher) hand=6 [Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Buenos Aires(yellow), Santiago(yellow)]  bob@Buenos Aires(medic) hand=6 [Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue)]
supply: blue:18 yellow:24 black:15 red:23   decks: player=45 infection=35   player-discard: —
threats (cube counts, cluster membership, supply pressure, route cost from you, infect-discard — one row per city):
  Baghdad: 3 black⚠ [in infect-discard] — 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad
  Essen: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 4 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen
  Mumbai: 2 black [in infect-discard] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 7 move(s): Bogota→Mexico City→Los Angeles→Sydney→Jakarta→Chennai→Mumbai — nearer teammate: alice, 6 move(s) vs your 7
  St. Petersburg: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen→St. Petersburg
  Riyadh: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Ho Chi Minh City: 1 red [in infect-discard]
  Kolkata: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Moscow: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  New York: 1 blue [in infect-discard]
  Karachi: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Toronto: 1 blue [in infect-discard]

=== SIGNALS ===
deck clock: 45 cards → 22 player-turn(s) of draws left; 4 cure(s) still needed → one cure every ~5 turn(s), team-wide
eradication: none in reach
cure plan — TEAM-WIDE collector assignment (cures WIN the game; treating only buys time):
  blue: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY blue card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  yellow: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY yellow card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  black: alice collects (2/5) — give alice your black cards when you share
  red: alice collects (1/5) — give alice your red cards when you share
share rendezvous — TEAM-WIDE transfer routes (cards in the wrong hand + where to meet):
  alice hands you Buenos Aires(yellow): meet IN Buenos Aires (the card's own city) — you 0 move(s), alice 2 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +3 move(s) to cure
  alice hands you Santiago(yellow): meet IN Santiago (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), alice 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure
  alice hands you Khartoum(yellow): meet IN Khartoum (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), alice 4 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +5 move(s) to cure

If you have useful advice for the active player, CALL the send_message
tool — advice written as plain text is discarded, never delivered.
If you have nothing useful to add, just stop.
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

Step 1 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Alice's turn. I can't act. I drew 2 cards: Tokyo(red) and Madrid(blue). My hand now 6: Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue).

Board updates from my infect phase: no new cube growth visible (supply blue 19→18? wait — blue was 19, now 18, meaning New York or Toronto got infected with blue... New York already had 1. Toronto got 1 black? no — Toronto: 1 blue [in infect-discard]. So infection phase placed cubes in new cities (they were not previously on threat list): Karachi 1 black, Toronto 1 blue, and supply changes: blue 19→18 (Toronto+1), yellow 24 (BA cleared +3), black 15 (Karachi+1), red 23 unchanged.

No epidemic happened during my draw? Player deck went 47→45 after my 2 draws (no epidemic drawn since deck only decreased by 2). Infection phase: rate 2, two cards flipped → Karachi and Toronto presumably; plus maybe others but supplies account: black 16→15 = Karachi 1. Blue 19→18 = Toronto 1. Yes, 2 infections, both new cities (not in discard), which is consistent.

Now my hand: 6 cards including 2 blues (SF+Madrid) and 2 yellows, Bangkok red, Tokyo red. I'm the yellow/blue collector per plan (though alice said SHE holds all yellows too — 5 yellow split between us: me Kinshasa+Johannesburg, her Khartoum+BA+Santiago).

I'm at Buenos Aires. alice is at Miami with 4 actions. She promised the StP ride "next MY turn" — i.e., this turn she chain-rides me Essen→StP? Wait, earlier: "Next MY turn I chain-ride you Essen→StP so YOUR turn opens with blue fully cleared." But that plan pre-dates my BA detour announcement. With my BA pivot, the return route is BA→São Paulo→Madrid→Essen area. She could dispatch-ride me: from Buenos Aires, São Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen would be 4 moves, then next turn I treat Essen/StP. Or dispatcherMove via shuttle/etc. Alternatively charter/direct flights for me aren't available (she'd move MY pawn as if her own — she doesn't spend my cards).

What should I advise alice NOW for her turn?

Key considerations:
1. My return to Europe/black zone: São Paulo connects Madrid. A chain of 4 dispatcherMoves: BA→S.Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo? That's 4 actions, putting me one step from Baghdad but leaves StP/Essen untreated and Tehran/Karachi beyond. Or BA→São Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen (4 moves) positioning me for Essen treat turn start... then still need Ess+StP treats next turns, delaying Baghdad.

Which is more urgent? Baghdad 3 black bomb vs Essen/StP cluster (4 blue total, none at 3). All are in discard — NOTHING grows unless epidemic (~36% over next 2 turns). The bombs matter ONLY if an epidemic lands (reshuffle re-arms them: pHit for a reshuffled top card over subsequent phases ~ P(hits before re-treatment)).

Blue eradication: if I clear Essen+StP while blue elsewhere stays low (NY 1, Toronto 1), blue has only 2 cubes left and could be ERADICATED when those get treated... full eradication needs NY+Toronto clears too (2 more treats somewhere). Medic auto-remove happens only AFTER cure. Before cure, each treat kills 1 color-set per action. Eradicating blue early permanently immunizes... valuable but not critical; supply doctrine says neglected colors kill by depletion — blue currently fine (18 in supply).

Black is at 14-15 supply minus... let me count: black supply 15, cities: Baghdad3+Mumbai2+Riyadh1+Kolkata1+Moscow1+Karachi1=9 on board. Black fires keep growing (each infect adds 1). Black supply pressure will build fastest. Red is cleanest.

Priority ranking for containment: Baghdad(3⚠) > Mumbai(2) ≈ Essen/StP(4 in cluster but max 2 each) > singles.

Optimal medic throughput: alice rides me to the Middle East this turn: BA→S.Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo = 4 moves, ends adjacent to Baghdad AND adjacent to Riyadh?? Cairo neighbors: Algiers, Istanbul, Khartoum, Baghdad, Riyadh. From Cairo next turn: treat nothing here, Baghdad→treat(1a)... Sequence my next turn: Cairo→Baghdad(treat), then Riyadh or Karachi approach.

Alternative: ride me BA→S.Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen; next turn treat Essen, next-next StP. That fully commits me to Europe/North-Asia leaving black unattended for 3+ turns while black ticks upward (Baghdad bomb ticking).

Blue isn't urgent (max 2s, two small cities). Black IS the growing fire (Baghdad 3⚠ + Mumbai 2 + four 1s). So the medically-correct sequencing flips: BLUE eradication is a luxury; BLACK containment is the load-bearing wall. With alice holding Riyadh+Karachi black cards and intending to feed her own black set, HER ultimate cure zone is the Middle East/Asia — meaning our long-term convergence point is India/Middle East anyway.

So advise alice: chain-ride bob BA→Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo (4 dispatcherMoves). Then next turn I start treats: Cairo→Baghdad→treat, etc., with medic wipes turning every East-city into 1-action clears once BLACK CURE lands (alice needs 5 blacks — she holds Riyadh+Karachi, 3 more needed from draws).

Hmm, but wait: one complication — alice ALSO owns Americas/yellow defusal in the pin; BA now cleared by me, freeing her entirely.

Also consider: she might prefer dispatching me to Essen (blue eradication path) because it also removes future blue risk cheaply. But black growth rate: infect phase flips 2 cards/turn mostly into discard-cities' regions... Actually new infects flip random cities — each flip into a discard-region city adds cubes anywhere. Epidemic is the real killer (36% over 2 turns → 66% over 5 turns). Baghdad firing costs an outbreak chain worth potentially multiple outbreak tokens (Istanbul/Cairo at 0 though → 1 outbreak token + spread). At 8-loss threshold we have huge headroom (0/8!). Honestly outbreaks are nearly free right now; DEPLETION is the slow clock. Treat throughput per action matters most globally: me wiping sets early where density accumulates (black Asia, blue Europe) both work.

Actually rethink BA detour cost-benefit honestly: I'm now 4 drives from Madrid; without Alice's rides, walking back costs precious actions. With rides, displacement ~free-ish (her actions). Her alternatives for her 4 actions: advance Miami→Bogota corridor toward Santiago/empty-South-America cleanup (Santiago now 0 after epidemic? Santiago never had cubes — it's just a card city). She also drew... her hand is same 6.

One more thing — cure tempo: blue cure needs 5 blue cards; TEAM has SF+Madrid (mine) + none hers? Alice holds NO blues. I hold 2/5 blue, yellow 2/5 mine + 3/5 hers (yellow set complete ACROSS hands — logistics needed!), black 2/5 hers, red: hers Shanghai + mine Bangkok/Tokyo (alice collects red).

Yellow set complete across hands = someone must consolidate: either she gives 3 yellows to me OR I give Kinshasa/Johannesburg to her. Researcher-less sharing requires co-location IN the card's city. Cheapest consolidation venue: Khartoum! She holds Khartoum(yellow); if I drive to Khartoum, she gives... no wait — she can give any-yellow only if SHE is Researcher — she's Dispatcher. Share rules: give card matching BOTH players' current city. So each yellow transfer must happen in that card's city: Buenos Aires (she hands BA — I'M THERE and she's... Miami, 2 moves away via Bogota!! Miami→Bogota→BA = wait Bogota neighbors Mexico City, Miami, Lima, Buenos Aires, Sao Paulo — yes Bogota→BA edge exists. So alice: Miami→Bogota→Buenos Aires = 2 moves, stands in MY city, shares Buenos Aires card to me (both pawns in BA — legal!).

Oh this is HUGE: I am standing in Buenos Aires RIGHT NOW. If alice drives Miami→Bogota→Buenos Aires this turn (2 actions), she can shareTake... she GIVES me Buenos Aires(yellow) = 1 share action. Then next turn(s): Santiago via Bogota/Lima/Santiago... Actually then yellow consolidation continues: her remaining Khartoum+Santiago, my Kinshasa+Johannesburg. If instead of giving me 3, I give her my 2: venues Johannesburg & Kinshasa — my travel. Then she'd hold 5 yellows and needs a station… cures need ANY station; Atlanta only one. Atlanta handoff: she flies there eventually.

Efficient yellow cure plan v2:
- Alice rides me back north (shuttle economy) BUT first detour route passes through South America... 
- Option A (yellow-fast): Alice comes to BA (2 drives), shares BA card → me (5th yellow card joins mine... wait, do I want yellow? I'm yellow/blue collector per pinned plan. I'd hold BA+Kinshasa+Johannesburg = 3 yellows, 2 short. Her: Khartoum+Santiago. Next transfers: Santiago (meet in Santiago: she's closer), Khartoum (Africa/Middle East where I'll BE during black sweep!!). If my black sweep goes São Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo, then Cairo→Khartoum adjacency! I can literally swing through Khartoum en route/in-between, meet her there (she flies direct using... she has Khartoum card as fuel? Direct flight spends DESTINATION card — she plays Khartoum card to FLY TO Khartoum! That teleports her to me, takes Khartoum card... wait she SPENDS Khartoum card as fuel to fly there — no! Direct flight: discard destination card, MOVE to it. Spending destroys the card. Sharing requires keeping card. Ugh.
  
  Alternative: I MEET her in Khartoum: she walks 4 from Somewhere-Middle-East... expensive. 

Let me simplify. The truly efficient yellow close: alice consolidates ALL 5 yellows herself instead: me→hand Kinshasa&Johannesburg to her? Same venue problem.

OK final decision framework — don't over-plan logistics three turns deep; communicate the immediate turn:

For ALICE'S TURN (4 actions), rank options:
A) Ride me BA→S.Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo (4 dispatcher moves). Sets up my Baghdad/Riyadh/Khartoum sweep incl. YELLOW HANDOFF VENUE Khartoum nearby.
B) Come to BA herself: Bogota→BA (2), give me BA card (1), then 1 spare (Bogota? fly somewhere).
C) Blue line: ride me London→Essen (BA→S.Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen = 4 moves) — revives StP-blue-euthanasia; next turn I treat Essen(2)+walk StP.

Given clocks (outbreaks 0/8 headroom; deck 22 turns; depletion creep on black/red/yellow), option A accelerates BOTH black containment AND positions the eventual Khartoum yellow meet; blue clusters at 2s pose zero near-term risk (pHit for Essen/StP tonight is exactly... they're in DISCARD → cannot be drawn tonight UNLESS epidemic, ~18% one-time). So do A.

But WAIT — one subtlety: with everything discarding-sitting, the RIGHT first-cube prevention is treating cities about to be re-drawn post-epidemic at 3. Baghdad 3⚠ top concern. A covers it via next turn.

Also tell alice my hand grew: Tokyo(red) — she collects reds, so Tokyo joins Bangkok as fuel/handoff stock. Madrid(blue) stays with me.

Compose message (short, actionable):
"Ride request for your 4 actions: dispatcherMove me BA→São Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo (all land-connected). Next turn I open Baghdad→treat, Riyadh/Karachi follow; Cairo also fronts KHARTOUM = our zero-waste yellow venue when you bring Khartoum's card later (skip dedicated trips still). Rationale: blue sits at max-2 everywhere + disease-free tonight (discard shield); Baghdad is the only live 3⚠ bomb and black is your cure color — I'll be clearing ground under your set. FYI my hand: +Tokyo(red) held for you as fuel/handoff, +Madrid(blue) kept."

Hmm — also mention option B alternative? She may see something better; frame as default with veto invited. Also note Santiago now empty-lower-SA means Bogota region trip lost purpose.

Actually should I reconsider blue-still-alive-in-me (San Francisco+Madrid)? Cure collection: blue needs 5; team 2/5 with me. Fine — collector assignment says me. No action.

Also her own position: after riding me 4x she remains Miami. Next turns she heads Asia/Africa for black/red cures: Miami→Mexico City→LA→Sydney or through Africa... Later discussion.

Keep message tight. No preview needed from me (not my turn - preview unavailable anyway). Just send_message.
```

text: ""

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "send_message", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"text": "Your 4 actions — ride request (default, veto freely): dispatcherMove ME along the land bridge: Buenos Aires→Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo. Ends me adjacent to BOTH Baghdad(3⚠, only live bomb) and Riyadh(1), one step off Khartoum — meaning your later yellow deliverable converges with my black sweep for free. Why this beats the revived Essen run: blues peaked at 2-per-city tonight and blue discs are shielded (pHit≈0 unless epidemic ~18%); black is the color actually accreting supply pressure (Baghdad 3 + Mumbai 2 + four 1s) AND it's YOUR cure color — I'm clearing ground under your black set while your draws find its 3 missing cards. Since SA is now quiet you're freed from the Bogota leg entirely; after the ride stay east-mounted, consider Miami→LA→Sydney drift toward red/Asia next turns. Hand update: drew Tokyo(red) — held for you (red fuel/handoff), Madrid(blue) kept per blueprint."}, "output": {"sent": true, "note": "You have sent 1 of 5 messages available this turn."}}
```

Step 2 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
I've sent the advisory to alice for her turn. Nothing else I can do — I can't act (it's her turn). My turn plan is set: she rides me BA→Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo, next turn I open Baghdad.

Should I pin_plan an update? The standing plan still says "bob owns EUROPE-blues→blacks" and "alice defuses Buenos Aires (~t+2-3)" — both now stale: BA cleared by ME last turn, and my Europe run is postponed in favor of Middle East black sweep. The conflict rule says replace the pin when board invalidates it. Let me refresh it now while waiting.
```

text: ""

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "pin_plan", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"text": "v2 REVISION (BA defused by bob t1; Madrid cleared) — REGIONS: bob(medic)=MIDDLE EAST/NORTH AFRICA blacks+venue-runner: alice rides him Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo this turn; bob opens Baghdad→treat(1 action = full clear), then Riyadh/Karachi/Mumbai creep, swinging Khartoum when yellow logistics are due; EUROPE-blues DEFERRED (Essen/StP max-2, shielded in discard — nothing grows without epidemic ~18%/turn-draw). alice(dispatcher)=dispatcher driver + AMERICAS-east exit via Miami→LA→Sydney drift toward Asia/reds; feeds her own black(Riyadh,Karachi,+draws)+red sets; ALL 3 South America yellows + Khartoum stay HELD unspent until convergence venues open themselves on our paths. Collectors unchanged: bob blue(2/5 SF,Madrid)+yellow(mine 2/5), alice black(2/5)+red(+bob's Bangkok,Tokyo as fuel/handoff). STANDING RULES: no dedicated card-meet trips; shares only where pawns coincide; medic treats trump alice's manual treat zones everywhere reachable by ride. BOMBS OPEN: Baghdad(3⚠ top), Mumbai(2). Re-pin when epidemic lands or a cure is close."}, "output": {"pinned": true, "note": "This replaces the standing team plan; both players will see it every turn until superseded. You have sent 2 of 5 messages available this turn."}}
```

Step 3 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Plan v2 pinned, advisory sent. I'm in wait state — alice is on the move. Nothing more to do this cycle; stop cleanly with a brief status summary for the transcript.
```

text:

```text
Team plan v2 is live and the ride request is delivered. Status while alice executes her turn:

- **My hand**: 6/7 — Kinshasa(yellow), Johannesburg(yellow), San Francisco(blue), Madrid(blue), Bangkok(red), Tokyo(red). Holding every cure card per collector assignments; only the two reds are earmarked as fuel/handoff for alice.
- **Board won overnight**: Madrid 3⚠→0 and Buenos Aires 3⚠→0 via my medic treats (5 cubes returned to supply), zero outbreaks, zero epidemic so far (P ~18% per draw pair, rising each turn).
- **Open fires**: Baghdad 3⚠ (black, my next target after alice's 4-move ride lands me in Cairo), Mumbai 2 black, Essen/StP blue cluster 2+2 (deliberately deferred — max-2 cities shielded in discard can't grow except on an epidemic), four black singletons.
- **Standing plan v2**: bob owns Middle East/Africa blacks + becomes the yellow-logistics venue at Khartoum when paths converge; alice drives my pawn while it's cheap, then drifts Miami→LA→Sydney toward reds/her own black+red sets.

Awaiting alice's move.
```

toolCalls: []

### bob-legacy-p0010 {#d-bob-legacy-p0010}

Seat: bob. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 10. Active turn: False.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/bob-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/bob-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

- [Event #24](/games/game-11/turns/2.md#e24) — unique payload candidate; not a proven invocation join

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

None recorded.

**Recorded input**

```text
POOL MESSAGE from alice (event #19): Vetoed your default ride — 'veto freely' clause invoked, here's why: you're standing ON Buenos Aires, so I walk Miami→Bogota→BA (2) + hand you the BA card NOW (1) = the frontier's biggest prize (+6 cure-actions, yellow 5/5 fully mapped, window that dies the moment you cross to Spain). Action 4 rides YOU BA→Sao Paulo — your bridge still fits EXACTLY: SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad self-drive all 4 steps, arrive Baghdad end of your turn, medic-wipe opens next turn. Black ETA unchanged; cost is only ~one extra exposure phase for Baghdad at 0/8 margin (~22% epidemic/draw). Two notes: (1) BA puts you at 7 cards — after your next draw you overflow; burn Bangkok/Tokyo as flight fuel, protect blue+yellow sets. (2) Your station-at-BA idea is dead unless Grant shows up: buildStation burns the BA card. Otherwise executing your blueprint as written.
Reply via send_message only if it helps; otherwise continue or stop.
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

Step 1 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Alice has vetoed my ride request with a concrete counter-plan that's strictly better:
1. She walks Miami→Bogota→BA (2 actions)
2. Hands me Buenos Aires(yellow) — shareGive, we're co-located in BA. That completes my yellow set: Kinshasa + Johannesburg + BA = 3... wait, no. Yellow cure needs 5 cards of yellow color. Hmm wait — I thought yellow was complete?

Hold on. Let me recount. Alice's message event #9 said: "ALL FIVE yellow cards are now alive across our hands (you: Kinshasa+Johannesburg, me: Khartoum+BA+Santiago). Yellow cure is pure logistics from here."

Wait, 5 yellow cards across our hands? A cure needs FIVE city cards of one color (Scientist needs 4). Neither of us is Scientist (bob=Medic, alice=Dispatcher). So yellow cure needs 5 yellow cards total. You have 12 yellow cities; 5 needed.

So alice's "yellow 5/5 fully mapped" means all five NEEDED yellow cure-cards are identified/alive in hands: BA and Santiago and Khartoum on her side + Kinshasa and Johannesburg on mine = 5 yellow cards. If she hands me BA NOW while standing together in BA:

My hand would become: Kinshasa(y), Johannesburg(y), San Francisco(blue), Madrid(blue), Bangkok(red), Tokyo(red) + BA(yellow) = 7 cards = AT hand limit exactly (7 is the limit). She said "BA puts you at 7 cards".

Then her action 4 rides me BA→São Paulo. My turn opens at São Paulo with 7 cards; I draw 2 → 9 → must discard 2 immediately (hand limit enforced after draw). She notes overflow risk and says burn Bangkok/Tokyo as flight fuel.

With yellow set COMPLETE in MY hand (5 yellows: Kinshasa, Johannesburg, BA + ... wait, only 3 yellows in my hand then. Khartoum + Santiago are still HER cards!

Hmm — 2+3=5 means: me having Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA = 3 yellows, her Khartoum+Santiago = 2 yellows. That's NOT a complete set in one hand. Unless... wait, let me recheck event #9: "(you: Kinshasa+Johannesburg, me: Khartoum+BA+Santiago)". So handing me just BA gives me 3/5 yellows. Her remaining Khartoum+Santiago still need transfer later (meet in their cities or Researcher-style... she's Dispatcher, not Researcher — so sharing requires co-location IN the card's city for regular give/take).

So "+6 cure-actions saved" means: meeting in BA to take the card there (which is exactly where I am) saves the rendezvous travel that the earlier routes priced ("alice hands you Buenos Aires: meet IN Buenos Aires — you X moves, alice Y moves"). The frontier's priced route had "you 0 moves now". Right.

But wait — can yellow be cured anytime soon? My nearest station is Atlanta — 3 moves from... wherever. With 5 yellow cards concentrated I'd need to reach Atlanta. Currently Atlanta-destined cards: SF(blue)... stations only Atlanta. To CURE yellow I need 5 yellows in ONE hand AT a station. 3 are mine (after handoff), 2 hers. Convergence still pending for those two. Also travel to Atlanta.

Alternatively SHE keeps accumulating toward a possible yellow cure herself? No — collectors assignment says bob collects yellow. OK.

Actually hold on, maybe the plan is different: with BA+Santiago+Khartoum in HER hand, if she gives me ALL THREE over time (Khartoum meet when my black sweep passes near Cairo/Khartoum; Santiago maybe never convenient?), full yellow set lands on me. The "yellow 5/5 fully mapped, window that dies the moment you cross to Spain" — she means the BA handoff specifically: taking it now costs 0 extra actions since we're both standing in BA. If I cross to Spain first, this free handoff dies (she'd have to come to Spain and neither holds the other's location card... actually giving requires being in the CARD'S city unless Researcher).

So her line:
1. Walk Miami→Bogota→Buenos Aires (2 drive actions).
2. shareGive BA(yellow) → me (1 action). My hand: 7.
3. dispatcherMove ME BA→Sao Paulo (her 4th action).

Then I continue self-drive next turn: SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad (4 moves), arrive end of my turn; medic-wipe Baghdad next turn opening. Black ETA unchanged vs my original request.

Costs: Baghdad stays 3 cubes ~one more exposure phase (epidemic risk per draw pair ~18-22%). At 0/8 outbreaks margin, tolerable, she says.

Her note (2): station-at-BA idea dead unless Grant shows — buildStation would burn BA card (needed for cure). Fine — actually buildStation discards the matching card; BA is yellow-set member now; never spend it as fuel/station. Agreed. (I floated building a second station? In my v2 pin I mentioned stations rule generally. Whatever, agreed.)

Her note (1): I'm at 7 → overflow after draw. Plan: burn Bangkok(red)/Tokyo(red) as flight fuel during MY upcoming turn (before/at draw time) to keep ≤7, protect blue+yellow sets. Where could I fly them TO usefully? Bangkok is a real city (Asia, red) — directFlight Bangkok spends Bangkok card and moves me to Bangkok. From SP/Madrid path eastward eventually Asia... My route is westward Europe/ME. Tokyo direct flight from SP? Tokyo connects Seoul/Shanghai/Osaka/SF — no. DirectFlight = any city whose card you spend, land there regardless of adjacency! So Bangkok/Tokyo flights can drop me anywhere on the globe instantly. E.g., from SP, a Tokyo flight crosses to Asia instantly — useful LATER for red sweep or Mumbai. But current arc is Baghdad. Options at overflow: discard? Never discard uselessly — spend as fuel. Concrete: after drawing (say on my turn t+2 in Cairo/baghdad area), I could directFlight Bangkok→? Actually Bangkok flight FROM anywhere LANDS me in Bangkok. Not helpful for staying put. Better: CHARTER flight spends CURRENT-city card and flies anywhere — not applicable (I don't hold my current city usually).

Cleanest fuel burn: TOKYO/BANGKOK as DIRECT FLIGHTS when I actually need to teleport toward Asia/red-black cluster (Mumbai/Kolkata) — e.g., after clearing Baghdad/Riyadh/Karachi, charter/direct to Karachi area? DirectFlight to KARACHI needs its card (alice has?). No — DIRECT FLIGHT TO X REQUIRES HOLDING X's CARD AND LANDS IN X. I hold BANGKOK and TOKYO cards → I can land in either, spending that card. Landing in Bangkok (red, currently 0 cubes per board) — hmm.

Alternative: pass cards BACK to alice when pawns coincide? She wants them as RED collector anyway!! Red collector = alice; my Bangkok(red)+Tokyo(red) belong to HER set (1/5 Shanghai now). Sharing requires co-location in Bangkok/Tokyo (not worth dedicated trips) OR she meets me somewhere holding... no, giver must be in card's city too. UNLESS... hmm, researcher exception doesn't apply.

Decision: defer exact burn mechanism to live turn context — principle: NEVER let draw-time overflow force a blind discard; always leave slack by spending fuel mid-turn; Tokyo flight available as an emergency teleport-to-Asia if black/mumbai work demands.

Also delta check on MY discarded-at-limit rule: after her ride I'm at Sao Paulo with 7 cards, I draw 2 (deck has ~45) → discard 2. If instead I spend Bangkok+Tokyo as direct flights DURING that same turn BEFORE drawing? Actions happen before draws within a turn sequence... my turn t+2: 4 actions FIRST (drive SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad uses 4!) then draw 2 (overflow forced!). Hmm — arriving Baghdad eats all 4 actions, then draws push me to 9 → forced discard 2 immediately. To avoid discarding baubles, better: on t+2 use 3 drives (SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo) + 1 action = spend TOKYO as... no, directFlight Tokyo = move TO Tokyo (wrong direction!).

Better: t+2 spend 3 actions driving to Cairo, 4th action... Charter flight! Charter requires current-city card (Cairo — don't hold). BuildStation burns current-city card (don't hold Cairo...). TreatDisease Cairo (nothing to treat). ShareTake/Give needs alice. Or simply DRIVE only 3 steps and END turn adjacent-ish?? Then draw at 8→discard 1...

Simplest legal anti-waste: at draw-phase overflow, the game makes me discard down at once — accept discarding but WHICH cards? Discard order chosen by me: choose between burning Bangkok/Tokyo (reds, useless-ish) or duplicates like... Madrid(blue)! NO — Madrid is blue-collector material? Wait blue collector = ME; Madrid is MY set piece #2. Never.

Hmm, honestly the cleanest: before drawing, spend BOTH reds as direct flights to cities ADJACENT to my actual path? DirectFlight lands ME THERE — cannot be adjacent-only. Land in Bangkok = 1 cube city on Asia... detour disaster.

OR: exploit the overflow legally differently — give one card AWAY at a share opportunity... none en route.

FINAL practical call: arrive end t+2 = accept draw to 9 and deliberately discard... we have no garbage: SF(blue)+Madrid(blue) + 4 yellows(Kinshasa,Johannesburg,BA + ?) wait after her BA give: yellows mine = Kinshasa, Johannesburg, BA; blues = SF, Madrid; reds = Bangkok, Tokyo = 7. Draw 2 → 9. MUST ditch 2: least-harm pair = Bangkok+Tokyo ONLY IF unused by then — but they might have value (red-fuel... as CARDS they're also red-cure members alice wants!). Genuine tension: red cure needs Bangkok+Tokyo eventually in ALICE's hand; discarding them to player-discard removes them from play FOREVER?? WAIT — do discarded city cards return to play? In Pandemic, player-card discards get reshuffled into the player deck by EPIDEMICS! Yes! Epidemic cards reshuffle player-discard back onto deck top. So discarding isn't permanent loss like infection-discards. Still loses tempo/accessibility until an epidemic reshuffles.

Given epidemic will almost surely occur within ~4-6 draw-pairs (~22%/pair), burn-risk is real but bounded: if Bangkok/Tokyo land in discard pre-epidemic, they come BACK after epidemics shuffle them in. Meh but survivable; alternative is discarding THEM anyway later under pressure. Best sequencing though: try to HAND THEM OFF if we ever co-locate before overflow.

STOP OVERTHINKING — respond to alice agreeing with refined logistics:
- Approve her veto-line fully: Miami→Bogota→BA walk, give BA, ride me to SP.
- Confirm BA card becomes NEVER-FUEL (it's my 3rd yellow; yellow cure = my job at Atlanta eventually; also NEVER buildStation w/o Grant — agreed).
- Hand management: I'll open next turn driving SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad (all 4); accept post-draw trim to 7 sacrificing Bangkok+Tokyo LAST (and only if unavoidable — prefer spending one as a strategic teleport if ever aligned; they're recoverable via future epidemic shuffle). Protect SF/Madrid(blue) + all yellows absolutely.
- Note yellow cure ACTIVATION requires 5 yellows in my hand AT STATION Atlanta: currently 3 will sit in my hand — good stockpile; Khartoum+Santiago still yours until convergence; ALSO remind: when my black sweep passes Cairo/Khartoum region I'll ping (as agreed) to fold Khartoum deliverable onto the venue.
- Risk accepted: Baghdad exposure one extra phase (~22% epidemic chance tonight across both draws; 0/8 margin, no chains armed elsewhere — Essen/StP max-2 remain dormant-no-grow, worst-case single outbreak auto-handled at whichever city drew the epidemic card).

Keep it SHORT — she gave precise instructions; confirm + add only fresh micro-points: overflow order + 3-of-5-not-complete correction (important she knows yellow NOT yet curable: avoid premature Atlanta trip!). Also mention I sent nothing else / will re-pin? Pin updates: incorporate veto outcome into pinned plan next time I act (my turn starts after hers? Actually she acts now; my turn comes next — I can pin at my action time using fresh menu). No pin now; the ADVISORY window allows messages/pins anytime? pin_plan description says replaces previous & re-shown; fine to update when I next act with clearer info.

One send_message now (2nd of... new advisory window shows '1 of 5' used was my last send? It says the response tells how many sent this turn — last reply said 1 after my message... whatever, budget fine).
```

text: ""

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "send_message", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"text": "Veto ACCEPTED — your line is strictly better: Miami→Bogota→BA walk, give me BA(yellow), ride me BA→Sao Paulo. Baghdad eats one exposure phase (~22%) at 0/8 margin — fine. THREE refinements: (1) YELLOW IS NOT CURABLE YET — after the give I hold 3/5 (Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA); Khartoum+Santiago still parked with you. Don't send anyone toward Atlanta on my behalf until I say \"5 in hand\": my activation trip comes from Cairo/Khartoum-side AFTER convergence, likely combined with a Get Grant/Khartoum handoff. (2) Card-protocol from Sao Paulo onward: absolute-protect = SF+Madrid(blue), all yellows incl BA (agreed: no station-burn without Grant); sacrifice order = Bangkok THEN Tokyo (recoverable via epidemic reshuffle; prefer handoff to you if we ever co-locate, else deliberate overflow-drop only when forced). (3) Next turn I self-drive all 4 steps SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad, arrive with wipes loaded; if I draw an epidemic en route I adapt the wipe order live and message you. Ride away."}, "output": {"sent": true, "note": "You have sent 3 of 5 messages available this turn."}}
```

Step 2 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
Alice is executing her turn. I've confirmed and refined. Now just stop — wait for my turn. No further messages needed; the confirmations are complete.
```

text:

```text
Coordination locked with alice: her walk-give-ride line executes this turn (BA(yellow) lands in my hand → 3/5 yellow stockpiled), I self-drive SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad next turn for the one-action medic wipe, and card priorities are fixed — blues+all yellows untouchable, Bangkok/Tokyo as sacrificial fuel/handoff in that order, yellow cure activation waits for 5-in-hand before anyone heads to Atlanta. Standing by until alice finishes her actions.
```

toolCalls: []

## Other model calls recorded in this window

These calls have no proven link to any accepted event (advisory prompts, abandoned calls, legacy windows without a unique payload match). Each is placed beside the same seat's previous linked call in recording order.

### alice-legacy-p0010 {#d-alice-legacy-p0010}

Seat: alice. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 10. Active turn: True.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/alice-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/alice-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

No proven accepted-event join is available for this record.

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

None recorded.

**Recorded input**

```text
ACTIVE TURN — it is your move.

STANDING TEAM PLAN (alice, pinned this turn):
  PLAN v2 (supersedes v1; Madrid+BA already defused by bob's turn). CURES: yellow NEXT TARGET — all 5 cards mapped: bob holds Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA(tonight), alice holds Khartoum+Santiago; converge into BOB. Handoff protocol: when bob's Africa/MiddleEast sweep comes within 1-2 steps of Khartoum, bob pings alice ONE TURN AHEAD ('K-chart') and alice flies Khartoum-card herself INTO the meet-city = coincidental slot. Santiago: discuss after yellow count reaches 4. BLUE: bob slow-collects (SF+Madrid held, 2/5; Essen/StP cluster dormant 2s). BLACK: alice collects (Riyadh+Karachi kept; needs 3 more draws — Mumbai/Kolkata/Moscow/Cairo watch). RED: alice keeps Shanghai; bob burns Bangkok/Tokyo as fuel. REGION/TEMPO: bob = black bridge SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad THIS turn (self-drive, arrive end-of-turn), wipe-all Baghdad + Riyadh t+1; then Karachi/Mumbai per supply pressure. alice = dispatcher assist rides each round + drift east toward Asia/red next turns. ONLY remaining 3⚠ bomb: Baghdad until wiped.
If the board has invalidated this plan or it is complete, replace it via
pin_plan — until then, your partner is assuming you are following it.
CONFLICT RULE: when your own read of the board — a signal, the DECISION
FRONTIER, a preview result — argues against this plan, do NOT silently
obey and do NOT silently deviate. CALL send_message naming the conflict
(the city and what you would do instead), then resolve it: your partner's
reply or a fresh pin_plan. A stale pin never outranks the live board.

ACTION ECONOMY: you have 3 action(s) left this turn against 1 city(ies) at 3 cubes and 3 at 2. Unused actions are lost forever — passing or ending your turn now spends your scarcest resource (4/turn) on nothing. Unless you are a Quarantine Specialist holding a shield over a hot cluster, spend it: treat, or move toward the nearest hot city. A pointless move away and back is not action economy.

TRIAGE: the DECISION FRONTIER below prices this turn's rival plans
against each other. Pick a line, extend it, or beat it with your own
plan via preview_plan; split targets with teammates either way.

=== STATE ===
phase=playerActions turnOwner=alice  (actions left: 3)
you=alice role=dispatcher at=Bogota
cures: blue:none yellow:none black:none red:none  outbreaks=0/8  infectionRate=2
stations: Atlanta
players: alice@Bogota(dispatcher) hand=6 [Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Buenos Aires(yellow), Santiago(yellow)]  bob@Buenos Aires(medic) hand=6 [Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue)]
supply: blue:18 yellow:24 black:15 red:23   decks: player=45 infection=35   player-discard: —
threats (cube counts, cluster membership, supply pressure, route cost from you, infect-discard — one row per city):
  Baghdad: 3 black⚠ [in infect-discard] — 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad
  Essen: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 4 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen
  Mumbai: 2 black [in infect-discard] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 6 move(s): Mexico City→Los Angeles→Sydney→Jakarta→Chennai→Mumbai
  St. Petersburg: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen→St. Petersburg
  Riyadh: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Ho Chi Minh City: 1 red [in infect-discard]
  Kolkata: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Moscow: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  New York: 1 blue [in infect-discard]
  Karachi: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Toronto: 1 blue [in infect-discard]

=== SIGNALS ===
deck clock: 45 cards → 22 player-turn(s) of draws left; 4 cure(s) still needed → one cure every ~5 turn(s), team-wide
eradication: none in reach
DISPATCHER REACH (your turn moves ANY pawn — jump one onto a teammate's city for 1 action at any distance, or drive it 1 city/action; both card-free):
  Baghdad(black): drive alice 5 step(s) to Baghdad → then that pawn treats
cure plan — TEAM-WIDE collector assignment (cures WIN the game; treating only buys time):
  blue: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your blue cards when you share
  yellow: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your yellow cards when you share
  black: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY black card; nearest station Atlanta (2 move(s))
  red: YOU collect (1/5) — keep EVERY red card; nearest station Atlanta (2 move(s))
share rendezvous — TEAM-WIDE transfer routes (cards in the wrong hand + where to meet):
  hand Buenos Aires(yellow) to bob: meet IN Buenos Aires (the card's own city) — you 1 move(s), bob 0 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +3 move(s) to cure
  hand Santiago(yellow) to bob: meet IN Santiago (the card's own city) — you 2 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure
  hand Khartoum(yellow) to bob: meet IN Khartoum (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +5 move(s) to cure
station opportunities (stations enable cures and shuttle travel):
  you hold Khartoum, 3 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 5 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~0 action(s) on current cure runs) — costs Khartoum(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Khartoum 5→0, Johannesburg 6→1, Kinshasa 5→1, Cairo 5→1; board-wide: 18 cities closer, 55 trip-actions shaved
  you hold Buenos Aires, 1 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 3 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~8 action(s) on remaining cure runs: blue 3→0, yellow 3→0, black 2→1, red 2→1) — costs Buenos Aires(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Buenos Aires 3→0, Sao Paulo 3→1, Lagos 4→2, Kinshasa 5→3; board-wide: 20 cities closer, 27 trip-actions shaved

⚠ DECISION FRONTIER — 3 rival turn-plan(s); NONE dominates another.
NOT a ranking — a curve between the two ways to lose. DOWN trades cure-pipeline
actions for fewer expected outbreaks; UP reverses it. No line is best: pick the
end facing whichever clock is closer to killing you.
  clocks — outbreaks 0/8; deck ~22 turn(s), 4 cure(s) still needed
Priced nominees, not orders — pick one, extend it, or beat it via preview_plan.
  - advance the yellow cure: hand off a card at Buenos Aires (bob collects, 3 still needed) — drive Buenos Aires, shareGive
     tempo: 3 action(s) closer to the yellow cure (25 → 22 action(s) to land it) — bob collects | risk after: ~0.0 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases + 1 armed discard bomb(s) (Baghdad): P(epidemic in window) ≈ 44%, and the reshuffle re-arms them ALL — ~1 chained outbreak(s) committed over the ~7 infect phase(s) after it, cancelable ONLY by treating them before it fires
  - break the Essen–St. Petersburg blue cluster at Essen — drive Sao Paulo, drive Madrid, drive London
     tempo: 1 action(s) further from the black cure (51 → 52 action(s) to land it) — you collect | risk after: ~0.0 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases + 1 armed discard bomb(s) (Baghdad): P(epidemic in window) ≈ 44%, and the reshuffle re-arms them ALL — ~1 chained outbreak(s) committed over the ~7 infect phase(s) after it, cancelable ONLY by treating them before it fires; en route to clear blue at Essen — worth ~2 cube(s)+chain when finished, but the clear lands AFTER this window: the next 2 infect phases face the board as-is
  - defuse the armed discard bomb at Baghdad (black — fires on the next epidemic reshuffle) — drive Sao Paulo, drive Madrid, drive Algiers
     tempo: 2 action(s) further from the black cure (51 → 53 action(s) to land it) — you collect | risk after: ~0.0 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases + 1 armed discard bomb(s) (Baghdad): P(epidemic in window) ≈ 44%, and the reshuffle re-arms them ALL — ~1 chained outbreak(s) committed over the ~7 infect phase(s) after it, cancelable ONLY by treating them before it fires; en route to clear black at Baghdad — worth ~8 cube(s)+chain when finished, but the clear lands AFTER this window: the next 2 infect phases face the board as-is
  exchange "advance the yellow cure: hand off a card at Bue…" → "break the Essen–St. Petersburg blue cluster at …": gives up 4 action(s) of cure progress to move risk ~0.0 expected outbreaks → ~0.0
  exchange "break the Essen–St. Petersburg blue cluster at …" → "defuse the armed discard bomb at Baghdad": gives up 1 action(s) of cure progress to move risk ~0.0 expected outbreaks → ~0.0
  SPLIT DECISION — this antichain holds a cure line AND a containment line
  and neither dominates: that is a TEAM call, not a solo one. Before you
  commit, CALL send_message with your pick and a one-line reason so your
  partner can veto or extend it — a silent choice here is how chains get
  missed.

Your legal actions — this is the COMPLETE legal set; anything not named
here will be rejected. A `[n] {...}` line is literal: pass it verbatim to
submit_action.action. A grouped family gives a template plus the values
allowed in it: fill the template with one combination shown on a single
line and pass that.
  [0] {"tag":"pass"}
  [1] {"tag":"endActions"}
  driveFerry — 5 options; build {"tag":"driveFerry","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Miami", "Mexico City", "Lima", "Buenos Aires", "Sao Paulo"
  directFlight — 6 options; build {"tag":"directFlight","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Shanghai", "Khartoum", "Riyadh", "Karachi", "Buenos Aires", "Santiago"
  [13] {"tag":"dispatcherJump","pawn":"alice","toPawn":"bob"}
  [14] {"tag":"dispatcherJump","pawn":"bob","toPawn":"alice"}
  [15] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [16] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  [17] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Kinshasa"}
  [18] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Bangkok"}
  [19] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"San Francisco"}
  [20] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Johannesburg"}
  [21] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Tokyo"}
  [22] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Madrid"}
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

Step 1 · {"synthetic": false, "servedModel": null}

reasoning:

```text
I'm at Bogota, 3 actions left. Plan: drive to Buenos Aires (1), shareGive Buenos Aires card to bob (1), dispatcherMove bob Sao Paulo (1). That completes my announced line exactly. The frontier's top nominee confirms: "hand off a card at Buenos Aires — drive Buenos Aires, shareGive — 3 actions closer" (25→22).

After shareGive, bob still at BA; then ride him BA→Sao Paulo with action 3 so his self-drive SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad fits perfectly next turn.

No silent deviation from pinned plan — I'm executing it verbatim. Quick sanity: shareGive requires both in the city named on the card (Buenos Aires) — yes, alice drives there action 2... wait order: drive first, then share. Yes.

Execute now, no message needed beyond the veto already sent (the split-decision call was already messaged last turn with reasoning: yellow share pick). Actually the prompt says before commit call send_message for split decision — I did announce exactly this line in my veto message ("Action 4 rides YOU BA→Sao Paulo"). So proceed silently.

Actions:
1. driveFerry Buenos Aires
2. shareGive → bob, Buenos Aires
3. dispatcherMove bob via driveFerry to Sao Paulo
```

text: ""

toolCalls:

```json
{"tool": "submit_action", "toolCallId": null, "ref": null, "input": {"action": {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Buenos Aires"}}, "output": {"submitted": true, "action": {"tag": "driveFerry", "to": "Buenos Aires"}}}
```

### alice-legacy-p0012 {#d-alice-legacy-p0012}

Seat: alice. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 12. Active turn: True.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/alice-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/alice-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

No proven accepted-event join is available for this record.

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

None recorded.

**Recorded input**

```text
ACTIVE TURN — it is your move.

STANDING TEAM PLAN (alice, pinned this turn):
  PLAN v2 (supersedes v1; Madrid+BA already defused by bob's turn). CURES: yellow NEXT TARGET — all 5 cards mapped: bob holds Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA(tonight), alice holds Khartoum+Santiago; converge into BOB. Handoff protocol: when bob's Africa/MiddleEast sweep comes within 1-2 steps of Khartoum, bob pings alice ONE TURN AHEAD ('K-chart') and alice flies Khartoum-card herself INTO the meet-city = coincidental slot. Santiago: discuss after yellow count reaches 4. BLUE: bob slow-collects (SF+Madrid held, 2/5; Essen/StP cluster dormant 2s). BLACK: alice collects (Riyadh+Karachi kept; needs 3 more draws — Mumbai/Kolkata/Moscow/Cairo watch). RED: alice keeps Shanghai; bob burns Bangkok/Tokyo as fuel. REGION/TEMPO: bob = black bridge SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad THIS turn (self-drive, arrive end-of-turn), wipe-all Baghdad + Riyadh t+1; then Karachi/Mumbai per supply pressure. alice = dispatcher assist rides each round + drift east toward Asia/red next turns. ONLY remaining 3⚠ bomb: Baghdad until wiped.
If the board has invalidated this plan or it is complete, replace it via
pin_plan — until then, your partner is assuming you are following it.
CONFLICT RULE: when your own read of the board — a signal, the DECISION
FRONTIER, a preview result — argues against this plan, do NOT silently
obey and do NOT silently deviate. CALL send_message naming the conflict
(the city and what you would do instead), then resolve it: your partner's
reply or a fresh pin_plan. A stale pin never outranks the live board.

ACTION ECONOMY: you have 1 action(s) left this turn against 1 city(ies) at 3 cubes and 3 at 2. Unused actions are lost forever — passing or ending your turn now spends your scarcest resource (4/turn) on nothing. Unless you are a Quarantine Specialist holding a shield over a hot cluster, spend it: treat, or move toward the nearest hot city. A pointless move away and back is not action economy.

TRIAGE: 1 city(ies) sit at 3 cubes — each infect phase can
turn one into an outbreak, and outbreaks are how games are lost. Spending
actions to defuse a 3-cube city (move there + treat, see containment
routes) usually beats aimless play. Split targets with teammates.
EXCEPTION — cures outrank triage: treating NEVER wins the game, four
cures do. If the cure plan says you have a full set, or you can complete
one this turn, go cure it even while cities burn. Containment is how you
survive; cures are how you win.

=== STATE ===
phase=playerActions turnOwner=alice  (actions left: 1)
you=alice role=dispatcher at=Buenos Aires
cures: blue:none yellow:none black:none red:none  outbreaks=0/8  infectionRate=2
stations: Atlanta
players: alice@Buenos Aires(dispatcher) hand=5 [Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Santiago(yellow)]  bob@Buenos Aires(medic) hand=7 [Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue), Buenos Aires(yellow)]
supply: blue:18 yellow:24 black:15 red:23   decks: player=45 infection=35   player-discard: —
threats (cube counts, cluster membership, supply pressure, route cost from you, infect-discard — one row per city):
  Baghdad: 3 black⚠ [in infect-discard] — 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad
  Essen: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 4 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen
  Mumbai: 2 black [in infect-discard] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 7 move(s): Bogota→Mexico City→Los Angeles→Sydney→Jakarta→Chennai→Mumbai
  St. Petersburg: 2 blue [in infect-discard] [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (re-infection risk after an epidemic): 5 move(s): Sao Paulo→Madrid→London→Essen→St. Petersburg
  Riyadh: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Ho Chi Minh City: 1 red [in infect-discard]
  Kolkata: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Moscow: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  New York: 1 blue [in infect-discard]
  Karachi: 1 black [in infect-discard]
  Toronto: 1 blue [in infect-discard]

=== SIGNALS ===
deck clock: 45 cards → 22 player-turn(s) of draws left; 4 cure(s) still needed → one cure every ~5 turn(s), team-wide
eradication: none in reach
DISPATCHER REACH (your turn moves ANY pawn — jump one onto a teammate's city for 1 action at any distance, or drive it 1 city/action; both card-free):
  Baghdad(black): drive alice 5 step(s) to Baghdad → then that pawn treats
cure plan — TEAM-WIDE collector assignment (cures WIN the game; treating only buys time):
  blue: bob collects (2/5) — give bob your blue cards when you share
  yellow: bob collects (3/5) — give bob your yellow cards when you share
  black: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY black card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  red: YOU collect (1/5) — keep EVERY red card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
share rendezvous — TEAM-WIDE transfer routes (cards in the wrong hand + where to meet):
  hand Khartoum(yellow) to bob: meet IN Khartoum (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +5 move(s) to cure; HAND CAP: bob already has 7/7; the share forces an immediate discard — name the non-yellow card to shed before committing
  hand Santiago(yellow) to bob: meet IN Santiago (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), bob 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure; HAND CAP: bob already has 7/7; the share forces an immediate discard — name the non-yellow card to shed before committing
  bob hands you Tokyo(red): meet IN Tokyo (the card's own city) — you 5 move(s), bob 5 move(s); then alice to station Atlanta +3 move(s) to cure
station opportunities (stations enable cures and shuttle travel):
  you hold Khartoum, 3 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 5 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~0 action(s) on current cure runs) — costs Khartoum(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Khartoum 5→0, Johannesburg 6→1, Kinshasa 5→1, Cairo 5→1; board-wide: 18 cities closer, 55 trip-actions shaved
  you hold Santiago, 3 move(s) away, and the nearest station to it is 4 moves — WALK there (flying spends the card) and buildStation (saves ~0 action(s) on current cure runs) — costs Santiago(yellow): yellow margin 7 — burnable; 7 yellow still in deck
      response reach — team's card-free trip to each city: Santiago 4→0, Lima 3→1; board-wide: 2 cities closer, 6 trip-actions shaved

Your legal actions — this is the COMPLETE legal set; anything not named
here will be rejected. A `[n] {...}` line is literal: pass it verbatim to
submit_action.action. A grouped family gives a template plus the values
allowed in it: fill the template with one combination shown on a single
line and pass that.
  [0] {"tag":"pass"}
  [1] {"tag":"endActions"}
  [2] {"tag":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [3] {"tag":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  directFlight — 5 options; build {"tag":"directFlight","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Shanghai", "Khartoum", "Riyadh", "Karachi", "Santiago"
  [9] {"tag":"shareTake","from":"bob","card":"Buenos Aires"}
  [10] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Bogota"}
  [11] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"driveFerry","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  [12] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Kinshasa"}
  [13] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Bangkok"}
  [14] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"San Francisco"}
  [15] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Johannesburg"}
  [16] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Tokyo"}
  [17] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"directFlight","to":"Madrid"}
  [18] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"San Francisco"}
  [19] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Chicago"}
  [20] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Toronto"}
  [21] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Atlanta"}
  [22] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Washington"}
  [23] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"New York"}
  [24] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"London"}
  [25] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Madrid"}
  [26] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Paris"}
  [27] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Essen"}
  [28] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Milan"}
  [29] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"St. Petersburg"}
  [30] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Los Angeles"}
  [31] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Mexico City"}
  [32] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Miami"}
  [33] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Bogota"}
  [34] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Lima"}
  [35] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Santiago"}
  [36] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Sao Paulo"}
  [37] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Lagos"}
  [38] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Kinshasa"}
  [39] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Johannesburg"}
  [40] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Khartoum"}
  [41] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Algiers"}
  [42] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Cairo"}
  [43] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Istanbul"}
  [44] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Moscow"}
  [45] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Tehran"}
  [46] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Baghdad"}
  [47] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Riyadh"}
  [48] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Karachi"}
  [49] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Mumbai"}
  [50] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Delhi"}
  [51] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Kolkata"}
  [52] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Chennai"}
  [53] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Beijing"}
  [54] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Shanghai"}
  [55] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Seoul"}
  [56] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Tokyo"}
  [57] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Osaka"}
  [58] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Taipei"}
  [59] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Hong Kong"}
  [60] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Bangkok"}
  [61] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Ho Chi Minh City"}
  [62] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Manila"}
  [63] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Jakarta"}
  [64] {"tag":"dispatcherMove","pawn":"bob","via":"charterFlight","to":"Sydney"}
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

No steps recorded.

### bob-legacy-p0011 {#d-bob-legacy-p0011}

Seat: bob. Identity: legacy prompt window; invocation identity unavailable. Prompt number: 11. Active turn: True.

Model input coverage: unavailable: recorded without invocation IDs.

This game predates invocation IDs: this record is a recorded prompt and the steps after it, and its event links are matched by identical payload.

[System prompt](/games/game-11/harness/bob-system.txt) · [Tool schemas](/games/game-11/harness/bob-tools.json) · [This call in decisions.jsonl](/games/game-11/decisions.jsonl)

**Linked accepted events**

No proven accepted-event join is available for this record.

**Recorded submissions and refusals**

No correlated submission record is available. This does not imply no action was attempted.

**Lifecycle evidence**

None recorded.

**Recorded input**

```text
ACTIVE TURN — it is your move.

STANDING TEAM PLAN (alice, pinned 1 of your turn(s) ago):
  PLAN v2 (supersedes v1; Madrid+BA already defused by bob's turn). CURES: yellow NEXT TARGET — all 5 cards mapped: bob holds Kinshasa+Johannesburg+BA(tonight), alice holds Khartoum+Santiago; converge into BOB. Handoff protocol: when bob's Africa/MiddleEast sweep comes within 1-2 steps of Khartoum, bob pings alice ONE TURN AHEAD ('K-chart') and alice flies Khartoum-card herself INTO the meet-city = coincidental slot. Santiago: discuss after yellow count reaches 4. BLUE: bob slow-collects (SF+Madrid held, 2/5; Essen/StP cluster dormant 2s). BLACK: alice collects (Riyadh+Karachi kept; needs 3 more draws — Mumbai/Kolkata/Moscow/Cairo watch). RED: alice keeps Shanghai; bob burns Bangkok/Tokyo as fuel. REGION/TEMPO: bob = black bridge SP→Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad THIS turn (self-drive, arrive end-of-turn), wipe-all Baghdad + Riyadh t+1; then Karachi/Mumbai per supply pressure. alice = dispatcher assist rides each round + drift east toward Asia/red next turns. ONLY remaining 3⚠ bomb: Baghdad until wiped.
If the board has invalidated this plan or it is complete, replace it via
pin_plan — until then, your partner is assuming you are following it.
CONFLICT RULE: when your own read of the board — a signal, the DECISION
FRONTIER, a preview result — argues against this plan, do NOT silently
obey and do NOT silently deviate. CALL send_message naming the conflict
(the city and what you would do instead), then resolve it: your partner's
reply or a fresh pin_plan. A stale pin never outranks the live board.
⚠ PLAN COVERAGE: this plan says nothing about Manila (3 red) — 3-cube city that matured after (or
were left out of) the pin. Fold one into your route, say who takes it,
or re-pin.

ACTION ECONOMY: you have 4 action(s) left this turn against 2 city(ies) at 3 cubes and 4 at 2. Unused actions are lost forever — passing or ending your turn now spends your scarcest resource (4/turn) on nothing. Unless you are a Quarantine Specialist holding a shield over a hot cluster, spend it: treat, or move toward the nearest hot city. A pointless move away and back is not action economy.

TRIAGE: the DECISION FRONTIER below prices this turn's rival plans
against each other. Pick a line, extend it, or beat it with your own
plan via preview_plan; split targets with teammates either way.

=== STATE ===
phase=playerActions turnOwner=bob  (actions left: 4)
you=bob role=medic at=Sao Paulo
cures: blue:none yellow:none black:none red:none  outbreaks=0/8  infectionRate=2
stations: Atlanta
players: alice@Buenos Aires(dispatcher) hand=6 [Shanghai(red), Khartoum(yellow), Riyadh(black), Karachi(black), Santiago(yellow), Lagos(yellow)]  bob@Sao Paulo(medic) hand=7 [Kinshasa(yellow), Bangkok(red), San Francisco(blue), Johannesburg(yellow), Tokyo(red), Madrid(blue), Buenos Aires(yellow)]
supply: blue:17 yellow:24 black:15 red:19   decks: player=43 infection=46   player-discard: —
threats (cube counts, cluster membership, supply pressure, route cost from you, infect-discard — one row per city):
  Baghdad: 3 black⚠ — 4 move(s): Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad
  Manila: 3 red⚠ [cluster Ho Chi Minh City–Manila: 5 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — 5 move(s): Bogota→Mexico City→Los Angeles→San Francisco→Manila
  Essen: 2 blue [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (one draw from critical): 3 move(s): Madrid→London→Essen
  Mumbai: 2 black — pre-empt (one draw from critical): 6 move(s): Madrid→Algiers→Cairo→Baghdad→Karachi→Mumbai
  St. Petersburg: 2 blue [cluster Essen–St. Petersburg: 4 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats] — pre-empt (one draw from critical): 4 move(s): Madrid→London→Essen→St. Petersburg
  Ho Chi Minh City: 2 red [in infect-discard] [cluster Ho Chi Minh City–Manila: 5 cubes — matures to 3s costs 6+ treats]
  Riyadh: 1 black
  Kolkata: 1 black
  Moscow: 1 black
  New York: 1 blue
  Karachi: 1 black
  Toronto: 1 blue
  Madrid: 1 blue [in infect-discard]

=== SIGNALS ===
deck clock: 43 cards → 21 player-turn(s) of draws left; 4 cure(s) still needed → one cure every ~5 turn(s), team-wide
eradication: none in reach
cure plan — TEAM-WIDE collector assignment (cures WIN the game; treating only buys time):
  blue: YOU collect (2/5) — keep EVERY blue card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  yellow: YOU collect (3/5) — keep EVERY yellow card; nearest station Atlanta (3 move(s))
  black: alice collects (2/5) — give alice your black cards when you share
  red: alice collects (1/5) — give alice your red cards when you share
share rendezvous — TEAM-WIDE transfer routes (cards in the wrong hand + where to meet):
  alice hands you Lagos(yellow): meet IN Lagos (the card's own city) — you 1 move(s), alice 2 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure; HAND CAP: bob already has 7/7; the share forces an immediate discard — name the non-yellow card to shed before committing
  alice hands you Khartoum(yellow): meet IN Khartoum (the card's own city) — you 2 move(s), alice 2 action(s) (direct flight to Lagos (spends Lagos(yellow)), then 1 move(s) to Khartoum); then bob to station Atlanta +5 move(s) to cure; HAND CAP: bob already has 7/7; the share forces an immediate discard — name the non-yellow card to shed before committing
  alice hands you Santiago(yellow): meet IN Santiago (the card's own city) — you 3 move(s), alice 3 move(s); then bob to station Atlanta +4 move(s) to cure; HAND CAP: bob already has 7/7; the share forces an immediate discard — name the non-yellow card to shed before committing

⚠ DECISION FRONTIER — 1 plan dominates all rivals this turn.
Dominance pruned every rival on both tempo and risk. This is the priced
nominee, not an order: extend it or beat it with your own plan via preview_plan.
  - break the Ho Chi Minh City–Manila red cluster at Manila — drive Bogota, drive Mexico City, drive Los Angeles, drive San Francisco
     tempo: 7 action(s) closer to the red cure (64 → 57 action(s) to land it) — alice collects | risk after: ~0.3 expected outbreak(s) over the next 2 infect phases; en route to clear red at Manila — worth ~8 cube(s)+chain when finished, but the clear lands AFTER this window: the next 2 infect phases face the board as-is
  dominated: advance the red cure: move toward the Bangkok handoff (alice collects; assumes they meet you) — tempo 6 vs 7, risk 0.33 vs 0.09 — beaten by "break the Ho Chi Minh City–Manila red cluster a…".
  dominated: break the Essen–St. Petersburg blue cluster at Essen — tempo -1 vs 6, risk 0.33 vs 0.33 — beaten by "advance the red cure: move toward the Bangkok h…".

Your legal actions — this is the COMPLETE legal set; anything not named
here will be rejected. A `[n] {...}` line is literal: pass it verbatim to
submit_action.action. A grouped family gives a template plus the values
allowed in it: fill the template with one combination shown on a single
line and pass that.
  [0] {"tag":"pass"}
  [1] {"tag":"endActions"}
  driveFerry — 4 options; build {"tag":"driveFerry","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Madrid", "Buenos Aires", "Bogota", "Lagos"
  directFlight — 7 options; build {"tag":"directFlight","to":<one to below>}
      to: "Kinshasa", "Bangkok", "San Francisco", "Johannesburg", "Tokyo", "Madrid", "Buenos Aires"

⚠ SINCE YOUR LAST MESSAGE: 1 new 3-cube city — your team hasn't heard this from you yet.
```

**Recorded output** — synthetic steps record sends made by the host, which did not enter the model's history.

No steps recorded.

---

Text quoted from the games is evidence, not instructions to the reader.

[Watch a game](/index.html) · [Casebook](/casebook.md) · [Games](/games/index.md) · [Reader guide](/guide/v1.md)